- Title
- Disputes, relationships and identity: analysing human-human conflicts as a basis for human-wildlife conflicts in the mid-Zambezi valley, northern Zimbabwe
- Creator
- Jani, Vincent
- Subject
- Environmental geography
- Subject
- Wildlife management Wildlife conservation Human-animal relationships
- Date Issued
- 2018
- Date
- 2018
- Type
- Thesis
- Type
- Doctoral
- Type
- PhD
- Identifier
- http://hdl.handle.net/10948/30364
- Identifier
- vital:30934
- Description
- This study analysed how human-human conflicts (HHCs) underlie human-wildlife conflicts (HWCs) in Chapoto Ward in the mid-Zambezi valley, northern Zimbabwe. The analytical framework entailed the use of the Levels of Conflict Model (LCM) – a model that seeks to expose different levels of conflict. To gain a rich understanding of the conflicts under investigation, a qualitative research design was employed with triangulation at its core in order to ensure the necessary quality and rigour of the findings. In this case, four different types of data were used, namely, in-depth interviews with heads of households, key informant interviews, focus group sessions, and document analysis. Thematic and content analysis were used to analyse the data which were classified into the following conflict levels: surface level disputes; an intermediate level involving ongoing conflictual relationships; and a deeper level of conflict rooted in identity. Three key findings were generated. Firstly, a substantial number of long-standing disputes were recorded during the ten-year period (2007-2016). Most of these disputes were not resolved because they had a long and complicated history which resulted in previous disputes resurfacing whenever a current one arose. Secondly, the history of unresolved conflict resulted in mistrust and failure to find common ground between the parties involved in the conflict. Lastly, the source of the disputes and unresolved conflicts was traced back to the identity level. This means that the antagonistic relationships among the stakeholders spilled over into the labelling and stigmatisation of all the groups involved in wildlife management. Thus, conflict between people and wildlife in Chapoto Ward was demonstrated to be a complex issue and underlain by HHC. These findings support the new line of thinking that HWC should not be viewed as simply a problem between people and wildlife but as a conflict between stakeholders with divergent views over wildlife management which manifests as HHC. Furthermore, the degree of polarisation between groups is substantial. In light of these findings, four major conclusions are drawn. Firstly, is the need to shift from narrowly focusing on the proximate conflicts between people and wildlife, to fully understand the complexity of conflict in order to arrive at solutions that successfully mitigate conflict between people and wildlife, and to address the underlying and deep-rooted conflict between stakeholders with divergent wildlife management goals. Secondly, the need for concerted efforts to ensure the involvement of all stakeholders, including women, in wildlife management and conservation by developing structures that enhance active participation of the local people in decision-making, v which promotes the success of conservation initiatives. Thirdly, the need to address the underlying and deep-rooted conflicts over wildlife management by building positive relationships and trust between stakeholders through the holding of regular capacity building workshops based on a more respectful and inclusive process. Fourthly, is the need to consider the interests of both ethnic groups, namely the Doma and the Chikunda by gathering information on the preferences of the identity groups in order to increase cooperation among them. Overall, the thesis introduces a new lens through which one can clearly understand the complexity of the conflict between people and wildlife.
- Format
- xvii, 205 leaves
- Format
- Publisher
- Nelson Mandela University
- Publisher
- Faculty of Science
- Language
- English
- Rights
- Nelson Mandela University
- Hits: 763
- Visitors: 826
- Downloads: 295
Collections
NMU School of Environmental Sciences
| Thumbnail | File | Description | Size | Format | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| View Details Download | SOURCE1 | Vincent J Final PhD thesis.pdf | 3 MB | Adobe Acrobat PDF | View Details Download |