- Title
- Girls here and boys there : participatory visual methodology as pedagogy to facilitate gender sensitive practices with pre-service foundation phase teachers
- Creator
- Notshulwana, Robin Anne
- Subject
- Gender identity -- Psychological aspects
- Date Issued
- 2020
- Date
- 2020
- Type
- Thesis
- Type
- Doctoral
- Type
- PhD
- Identifier
- http://hdl.handle.net/10948/49385
- Identifier
- vital:41700
- Description
- This study explores how participatory visual methodology (PVM) might facilitate a deeper understanding of gender sensitive practices (GSP) in Foundation Phase (FP) pre-service teachers. Foundation Phase classrooms are not impervious to unequal gender practices and despite policies that promote gender equitable practices in schools and in society in general, most South African schools still engage in gendered practices that perpetuate inequality and gender based violence (GBV). While the topic of gender currently features in a South African university FP curriculum with the intention of promoting social justice, the pedagogy used to enable pre-service FP teachers to understand how gender works in schools seems to do nothing more than describe the problem and give cursory suggestions for creating gender equitable practices. Teachers are often unaware of how their own gendered identity influences their facilitation of the curriculum in a gendered way. This is important in South Africa, where gender inequality remains a problem and GBV is rife. This study adopted a qualitative approach and is located within the critical paradigm applying the principles of PVM. It drew on feminist poststructuralism and feminist pedagogy as theoretical lenses to frame the study and to make meaning of the data. Participants in the study were five female pre-service FP teachers who were purposively selected. Data were generated through the visual methods of family photo album, drawing and participatory video, which were first analysed using participatory analysis, and then using thematic analysis. The main purpose of the research was to explore how PVM can facilitate a deeper awareness of GSP in pre-service FP teachers. The secondary aim was to explore their understandings of gender and GSP and how these understandings might facilitate or inhibit GSP among pre-service FP teachers. The pre-service FP teachers’ understandings of gender were elicited using the self as an entry point to explore their own gendered identities which demonstrated their somewhat narrow understanding of how gender is reified in society through mechanisms such as dress and particular performances. They further understood that their own gendered selves can shift and change with time and context. Their understanding of gender further informed their understanding of GSP. The pre-service FP teachers understood GSP as going beyond interchanging roles of girls and boys and that it meant constantly engaging with their own understandings of gender; to review their constructions of FP learners, to see pedagogical moments to teach gender sensitivity, and to recognise that GSP extends beyond the classroom. Finally, the pre-service FP teachers articulated the circumstances that might enable or inhibit their GSP in their classrooms. They recognised how the powerful constructions of gender in a society influence their work, and how, in turn their work might influence society. This translated into them understanding how the ethos of the school might mirror and sustain the hegemonic discourse of society and at the same time how they might begin to question and disrupt the discourse sustained in school. The teacher education programme, with a vested interest in gender equality, is an important mechanism to begin disrupting hegemonic discourses perpetuated in schools. The findings suggest that through its potential for reflexivity and criticality, PVM enabled the pre-service FP teachers to see how their constructions of gender influence their own practices in schools. The findings have implications for FP teacher education programmes in the South African context. Faculties of education could revisit their curriculum to ensure that gender is infused throughout the curriculum, but more importantly, could consider ‘starting with the self’ (Kirk, 2009) as an impetus to learn about how gender is reified in society and in schools. In doing so, faculties of education could also consider tools of analysis such as a feminist poststructural theory to enable the pre-service FP teachers to deepen their understandings but also support the potential to articulate and make meaning of their experiences. Teacher educators could revisit their curriculum content to determine whether the content might perpetuate a narrow view of learning and learners especially with regards to gender and considering pedagogical choices that develop pre-service teachers’ ability to cultivate classroom environments that promote gender equality. Starting with the self is an entry point for pre-service FP teachers to examine their own understanding of gender and see how this might enable GSP in their professional work. PVM, aligned with a feminist pedagogy and feminist poststructuralism, facilitated such a process.
- Format
- xix, 347 leaves
- Format
- Publisher
- Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University
- Publisher
- Faculty of Education
- Language
- English
- Rights
- Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University
- Hits: 1639
- Visitors: 1651
- Downloads: 148
Collections
NMU School for Education Research and Engagement
| Thumbnail | File | Description | Size | Format | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| View Details Download | SOURCE1 | Notshulwana, R.pdf | 13 MB | Adobe Acrobat PDF | View Details Download |