Benthic assemblage structure, and the feeding biology of sixteen macroinvertebrate taxa from the Buffalo River, Eastern Cape, South Africa
- Authors: Palmer, Carolyn Gay
- Date: 1992
- Subjects: Aquatic invertebrates -- South Africa -- Eastern Cape Benthos -- South Africa -- Eastern Cape
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Doctoral , PhD
- Identifier: vital:5646 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1005328
- Description: The River continuum concept (RCC) (Vannote et al. 1980) attempted to provide a unifying theory of river function. The Functional Feeding Group (FFG) concept (Cummins 1973, 1974) became a major component of the RCC. The FFG concept provides testable hypotheses about the changes in proportions of FFGs along a downstream gradient in a river, in response to the changing nature of food resources. The following short-comings of the FFG concept have been identified: 1) the variability of macroinvertebrate feeding, 2) problems with gut analysis as a method for assigning taxa to FFGs, and 3) inconsistent criteria defining FFGs. The objective of this study was to investigate the macroinvertebrate fauna of the Buffalo River in order to assess the applicability of aspects of the RCC and the FFG concept. The specific aims of the study were: 1) to describe the distribution of macroinvertebrate assemblages in the Buffalo River; 2) to clarify aspects of the FFG concept listed above; 3) to establish whether selected taxa could be assigned to FFGs; 4) to assess whether the proportions of different FFGs in successive reaches of a southern African river conformed to the predictions of the RCC; and 5) to test whether a functional classification is a useful alternative to a taxonomic classification. Macroinvertebrates were collected seasonally from a variety of biotopes at three sites, one each in the upper, middle and lower reaches. Riffles were sampled in summer at 16 sites. Over 100 taxa were identified and an hierarchical classification was prepared using two-way indicator species analysis. Invertebrate assemblages in the narrow headwater stream were taxonomically distinct from those of the middle/lower reaches and were not positively associated with subjectively identified biotopes. Biotopes were characterised by distinct assemblages in the wider middle/lower reaches. Sixteen abundant taxa whose feeding had not been previously investigated were selected for feeding studies, four from the headwaters and 12 from the middle/lower reaches. Methods used included gut content analysis, behavioural observations, food choice experiments and morphological studies using scanning electron microscopy. Three aspects of the functional feeding group concept were clarified. 1) Dietary variability was assessed using gut contents as an index of diet. The gut contents of both early (small) and late (large) instar larvae of all 16 taxa collected from different sites and biotopes, and in different seasons were compared using a multifactor analysis of variance. For all taxa the most consistently significant differences in gut contents were between large and small larvae. These were due to differences in the amount of material in the gut and in varying amounts of rarer dietary items. Dietary variability did not prevent taxa from being assigned to FFGs. 2) Gut content analysis satisfactorily provided basic information about the feeding biology of taxa but proved to be an inadequate single method for positively assigning taxa to FFGs. 3) Before taxa could be assigned to FFGs the definitions for some FFG categories had to be described clearly. It is suggested that the term shredder be based on the observation of shredding and a predominance of leaf fragments in the foregut. The presence of algae was not diagnostic of scrapers and a morphological basis is suggested. A morphological basis for the brusher FFG is described for the first time. All 16 taxa were assigned to FFGs. Three headwater taxa were shredders ((Goerodes caffrariae (Lepidostomatidae), Dyschimus ensifer (Pisulidae), Afronemoura spp. (Notonemouridae)) and one was a collector:brusher (Adenophlebia auriculata (Leptophlebiidae). These results were consistent with RCC predictions. All 12 of the taxa from the middle/lower reaches were filterers or collectors and this result was also consistent with RCC predictions. The Hydropsychidae, Cheumtopsyche afra and Macrostemum capense, were passive net filterers; Neurocaenis reticulatus (Tricorythidae) was a passive setal filterer; Caenidae sp. Band Pseudocloeon maculosum (Baetidae) were active filterers; caenidae sp. A, and the Baetidae, Baetis harrisoni, Centroptilum excisum and Cloeon africanum, were collector: gatherers; the Leptophlebiidae, Choroterpes elegans and Choroterpes nigrescens, were collector:brushers; and Afronurus harrisoni (Heptageniidae) was a scraper. Gut content analyses alone were insufficient to assign taxa to FFGs, but when augmented by morphological and/or behavioural data, taxa could be assigned to FFGs with confidence. In all cases the FFG designation referred to the most frequent style of feeding. N. reticulatus, A. harrisoni and A. auriculata were particularly flexible in their feeding behaviour. A functional classification of macro invertebrates in the Buffalo River was compared with a taxonomic classification. In both cases similar groups were identified, but their taxonomic and functional descriptions yielded different information. It is suggested that functional and taxonomic classifications should be viewed as complementary rather than alternative options.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 1992
- Authors: Palmer, Carolyn Gay
- Date: 1992
- Subjects: Aquatic invertebrates -- South Africa -- Eastern Cape Benthos -- South Africa -- Eastern Cape
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Doctoral , PhD
- Identifier: vital:5646 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1005328
- Description: The River continuum concept (RCC) (Vannote et al. 1980) attempted to provide a unifying theory of river function. The Functional Feeding Group (FFG) concept (Cummins 1973, 1974) became a major component of the RCC. The FFG concept provides testable hypotheses about the changes in proportions of FFGs along a downstream gradient in a river, in response to the changing nature of food resources. The following short-comings of the FFG concept have been identified: 1) the variability of macroinvertebrate feeding, 2) problems with gut analysis as a method for assigning taxa to FFGs, and 3) inconsistent criteria defining FFGs. The objective of this study was to investigate the macroinvertebrate fauna of the Buffalo River in order to assess the applicability of aspects of the RCC and the FFG concept. The specific aims of the study were: 1) to describe the distribution of macroinvertebrate assemblages in the Buffalo River; 2) to clarify aspects of the FFG concept listed above; 3) to establish whether selected taxa could be assigned to FFGs; 4) to assess whether the proportions of different FFGs in successive reaches of a southern African river conformed to the predictions of the RCC; and 5) to test whether a functional classification is a useful alternative to a taxonomic classification. Macroinvertebrates were collected seasonally from a variety of biotopes at three sites, one each in the upper, middle and lower reaches. Riffles were sampled in summer at 16 sites. Over 100 taxa were identified and an hierarchical classification was prepared using two-way indicator species analysis. Invertebrate assemblages in the narrow headwater stream were taxonomically distinct from those of the middle/lower reaches and were not positively associated with subjectively identified biotopes. Biotopes were characterised by distinct assemblages in the wider middle/lower reaches. Sixteen abundant taxa whose feeding had not been previously investigated were selected for feeding studies, four from the headwaters and 12 from the middle/lower reaches. Methods used included gut content analysis, behavioural observations, food choice experiments and morphological studies using scanning electron microscopy. Three aspects of the functional feeding group concept were clarified. 1) Dietary variability was assessed using gut contents as an index of diet. The gut contents of both early (small) and late (large) instar larvae of all 16 taxa collected from different sites and biotopes, and in different seasons were compared using a multifactor analysis of variance. For all taxa the most consistently significant differences in gut contents were between large and small larvae. These were due to differences in the amount of material in the gut and in varying amounts of rarer dietary items. Dietary variability did not prevent taxa from being assigned to FFGs. 2) Gut content analysis satisfactorily provided basic information about the feeding biology of taxa but proved to be an inadequate single method for positively assigning taxa to FFGs. 3) Before taxa could be assigned to FFGs the definitions for some FFG categories had to be described clearly. It is suggested that the term shredder be based on the observation of shredding and a predominance of leaf fragments in the foregut. The presence of algae was not diagnostic of scrapers and a morphological basis is suggested. A morphological basis for the brusher FFG is described for the first time. All 16 taxa were assigned to FFGs. Three headwater taxa were shredders ((Goerodes caffrariae (Lepidostomatidae), Dyschimus ensifer (Pisulidae), Afronemoura spp. (Notonemouridae)) and one was a collector:brusher (Adenophlebia auriculata (Leptophlebiidae). These results were consistent with RCC predictions. All 12 of the taxa from the middle/lower reaches were filterers or collectors and this result was also consistent with RCC predictions. The Hydropsychidae, Cheumtopsyche afra and Macrostemum capense, were passive net filterers; Neurocaenis reticulatus (Tricorythidae) was a passive setal filterer; Caenidae sp. Band Pseudocloeon maculosum (Baetidae) were active filterers; caenidae sp. A, and the Baetidae, Baetis harrisoni, Centroptilum excisum and Cloeon africanum, were collector: gatherers; the Leptophlebiidae, Choroterpes elegans and Choroterpes nigrescens, were collector:brushers; and Afronurus harrisoni (Heptageniidae) was a scraper. Gut content analyses alone were insufficient to assign taxa to FFGs, but when augmented by morphological and/or behavioural data, taxa could be assigned to FFGs with confidence. In all cases the FFG designation referred to the most frequent style of feeding. N. reticulatus, A. harrisoni and A. auriculata were particularly flexible in their feeding behaviour. A functional classification of macro invertebrates in the Buffalo River was compared with a taxonomic classification. In both cases similar groups were identified, but their taxonomic and functional descriptions yielded different information. It is suggested that functional and taxonomic classifications should be viewed as complementary rather than alternative options.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 1992
Some aspects of the biology of Nassarius kraussianus (Dunker)(Gastropoda : Prosobranchia : Nassariidae), in the Bushman's River estuary, with particular reference to recolonisation after floods
- Authors: Palmer, Carolyn Gay
- Date: 1981
- Subjects: Gastropoda -- South Africa -- Eastern Cape , Estuarine biology -- South Africa -- Eastern Cape , Prosobranchia -- South Africa -- Eastern Cape
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , MSc
- Identifier: vital:5809 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1006934 , Gastropoda -- South Africa -- Eastern Cape , Estuarine biology -- South Africa -- Eastern Cape , Prosobranchia -- South Africa -- Eastern Cape
- Description: 1. The development of estuarine research in South Africa has been reviewed, and the present state of knowledge assessed. Little is known about many abundant estuarine species, and a previously unstudied prosobranch Nassarius kraussianus (Dunker), was selected for investigation. 2. The study area, a mudflat on the Bushmans River estuary, was divided into three habitat types: supratidal, intertidal and subtidal, each with a particular substratum and pattern of vegetation cover. The distribution of N. kraussianus is associated with the nature of the substratum and the degree of Zostera capensis Setchell cover. 3. A brief review of pertinent literature indicated the necessity of relating population parameters to environmental conditions. 4. The population biology of N. . kraussianus was investigated, and the size frequencies, sex ratios, and male/female size frequencies were recorded over three distinct periods: pre-flood, post-flood and recovery. 5. The Bushmans River flooded in July and August 1979, and the results of the flood have been described. The most immediate result was a period of low salinity, but the most persistant result was the deposition of silt, which had an important effect on the substratum and the Z. capensis beds. 6. The pre-flood population was characterised by patchy distribution, and by a large number of mature adults in relation to juveniles. Females were generally larger than males, and the sex ratio was 1:1. The presence of juveniles in consistantly low numbers indicated that reproduction may have been continuous, but that intraspecific adult/juvenile competition may have kept juvenile numbers low. 7. The post-flood period was characterised by extreme physical conditions, and the survival of a few adults. Juveniles were completely annihilated, and were absent until a few were spawned by the surviving adults towards the end of 1979 . Sex ratio was biased, and females predominated. 8. The recovery period began abruptly with the arrival of a large number of juveniles in the 2, 3 and 4 mm size classes. Recolonisation coincided with habitat recovery, and reqeneration of the Z. capensis cover. Recolonising juveniles grew quickly, reaching adult size in three months. After that, juveniles were spawned on the mudflat by the new population. During this period the sex ratio did not return to the pre-flood 1:1, but remained female biased. Males and females grew at the same rate over the period measured, but females were consistantly larger, indicating that at some stage female growth may be faster. 9. The recolonising juveniles arrived in a regenerated habitat, at a time when temperatures were high, and conditions for growth probably optimal. If intraspecific competition was a feature of the pre-flood population it would have been elimianted in the recovery phase, by the absence of adults. 10. N. kraussianus is apparently omnivorous and proabably not food limited. However, carrion, a limited resource, may be essential for growth to reproductive maturity. Adults and juveniles may compete for this resource, and any juveniles deprived of access to carrion may be stimulated to leave the parental habitat. 11. N. kraussianus is ovoviviparous, and carries up to 5 egg cases within the uterus. Each triangular egg case contains 1 egg which hatches after approximately 3 weeks, as a free swimming veliger. Yeligers metamorphose, and settle after 4-7 days, assuming a benthic mode of life. Ovoviviparity protects the developing embryo from the rigours of environmental extremes, and ensures that embryos are not swept out to sea . Additionally, veligers have a high probability of settling in the parental habitat. 12. This reproductive strategy has been compared with other prosobranchs, and the evolutionary trends within the Prosobranchia, and particularly the Nassariidae, have been related to their dispersal potential. 13. Developmental strategy is intimately related to recolonisation potential. Ovoviviparity, and the lack of pelagic larvae, did not limit the recolonisation potential of N. kraussianus, and recolonisation was probably effected by post-larval juveniles, which may disperse from neighbouring estuaries and coastal pools, by floating in coastal and tidal currents. Post-larval juveniles have two important advantages over larvae. They are less vulnerable to physical extremes, and they have a sturdy crennellated shell which probably affords them protection from predators. 14. Examples of larval recolonisation in estuarine populations have been reviewed, and the most fundamental conclusion of this work is that recolonisation is an important, and probably widespread, adaptation to estuarine conditions in South Africa.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 1981
- Authors: Palmer, Carolyn Gay
- Date: 1981
- Subjects: Gastropoda -- South Africa -- Eastern Cape , Estuarine biology -- South Africa -- Eastern Cape , Prosobranchia -- South Africa -- Eastern Cape
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , MSc
- Identifier: vital:5809 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1006934 , Gastropoda -- South Africa -- Eastern Cape , Estuarine biology -- South Africa -- Eastern Cape , Prosobranchia -- South Africa -- Eastern Cape
- Description: 1. The development of estuarine research in South Africa has been reviewed, and the present state of knowledge assessed. Little is known about many abundant estuarine species, and a previously unstudied prosobranch Nassarius kraussianus (Dunker), was selected for investigation. 2. The study area, a mudflat on the Bushmans River estuary, was divided into three habitat types: supratidal, intertidal and subtidal, each with a particular substratum and pattern of vegetation cover. The distribution of N. kraussianus is associated with the nature of the substratum and the degree of Zostera capensis Setchell cover. 3. A brief review of pertinent literature indicated the necessity of relating population parameters to environmental conditions. 4. The population biology of N. . kraussianus was investigated, and the size frequencies, sex ratios, and male/female size frequencies were recorded over three distinct periods: pre-flood, post-flood and recovery. 5. The Bushmans River flooded in July and August 1979, and the results of the flood have been described. The most immediate result was a period of low salinity, but the most persistant result was the deposition of silt, which had an important effect on the substratum and the Z. capensis beds. 6. The pre-flood population was characterised by patchy distribution, and by a large number of mature adults in relation to juveniles. Females were generally larger than males, and the sex ratio was 1:1. The presence of juveniles in consistantly low numbers indicated that reproduction may have been continuous, but that intraspecific adult/juvenile competition may have kept juvenile numbers low. 7. The post-flood period was characterised by extreme physical conditions, and the survival of a few adults. Juveniles were completely annihilated, and were absent until a few were spawned by the surviving adults towards the end of 1979 . Sex ratio was biased, and females predominated. 8. The recovery period began abruptly with the arrival of a large number of juveniles in the 2, 3 and 4 mm size classes. Recolonisation coincided with habitat recovery, and reqeneration of the Z. capensis cover. Recolonising juveniles grew quickly, reaching adult size in three months. After that, juveniles were spawned on the mudflat by the new population. During this period the sex ratio did not return to the pre-flood 1:1, but remained female biased. Males and females grew at the same rate over the period measured, but females were consistantly larger, indicating that at some stage female growth may be faster. 9. The recolonising juveniles arrived in a regenerated habitat, at a time when temperatures were high, and conditions for growth probably optimal. If intraspecific competition was a feature of the pre-flood population it would have been elimianted in the recovery phase, by the absence of adults. 10. N. kraussianus is apparently omnivorous and proabably not food limited. However, carrion, a limited resource, may be essential for growth to reproductive maturity. Adults and juveniles may compete for this resource, and any juveniles deprived of access to carrion may be stimulated to leave the parental habitat. 11. N. kraussianus is ovoviviparous, and carries up to 5 egg cases within the uterus. Each triangular egg case contains 1 egg which hatches after approximately 3 weeks, as a free swimming veliger. Yeligers metamorphose, and settle after 4-7 days, assuming a benthic mode of life. Ovoviviparity protects the developing embryo from the rigours of environmental extremes, and ensures that embryos are not swept out to sea . Additionally, veligers have a high probability of settling in the parental habitat. 12. This reproductive strategy has been compared with other prosobranchs, and the evolutionary trends within the Prosobranchia, and particularly the Nassariidae, have been related to their dispersal potential. 13. Developmental strategy is intimately related to recolonisation potential. Ovoviviparity, and the lack of pelagic larvae, did not limit the recolonisation potential of N. kraussianus, and recolonisation was probably effected by post-larval juveniles, which may disperse from neighbouring estuaries and coastal pools, by floating in coastal and tidal currents. Post-larval juveniles have two important advantages over larvae. They are less vulnerable to physical extremes, and they have a sturdy crennellated shell which probably affords them protection from predators. 14. Examples of larval recolonisation in estuarine populations have been reviewed, and the most fundamental conclusion of this work is that recolonisation is an important, and probably widespread, adaptation to estuarine conditions in South Africa.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 1981
- «
- ‹
- 1
- ›
- »