The unfair labour practice relating to benefits

Timothy, Andrea Francis

Title: The unfair labour practice relating to benefits
Creator: Timothy, Andrea Francis
Subject: Unfair labor practices -- South Africa
Subject: Employee fringe benefits -- South Africa
Subject: Labor laws and legislation -- South Africa
Date Issued: 2015
Date: 2015
Type: Thesis
Type: Masters
Type: LLM
Identifier: vital:10259
Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/d1021157
Description: The meaning of the term “benefits” in the context of unfair labour practice jurisprudence, having previously been unsettled for more than a decade, has now been settled by the Labour Appeal Court in the Apollo.1 Prior to Apollo,2 our courts have struggled to adopt a stance to maintain the distinction between disputes of rights and disputes of interest as separate compartments. The prevalent view at that stage was that, in order for an employee to lodge a dispute at the CCMA or Bargaining Council the employee would have to show that he or she had a right to the benefit that arises by virtue of contract, statute or collective agreement, failing which the CCMA or a Bargaining Council would not have the jurisdiction to determine the dispute, in which case it may constitute a dispute of interest and the employee will have to embark on an industrial action to secure a benefit. Apollo3 endorsed a previous decision of the Labour Court,4 i.e. by placing “benefits” into the following two categories: (1) Where the dispute is about a demand by employees concerning their benefits, it can be settled by way of industrial action. (2) Where the dispute concerns the fairness of the employer's conduct, it must be settled by way of adjudication or arbitration. As a result of the above categorisation, the CCMA or Bargaining Council may adjudicate a dispute relating to benefits where there is a pre-existing benefit and the employer refuses to comply with its obligation towards the employer in that regard. It may also adjudicate disputes relating to the provision of a car allowance (i.e. where the employer retains the discretion to grant or withhold the allowance) and disputes relating to the provision of bonuses (i.e. where the employer retains the discretion to grant or withhold the bonus). In this treatise, I set out the history and development of the legislation in relation to the concept of “benefits” (in the context of unfair labour practice) so as to understand how our Labour Appeal Court has now come to settle the issues above.
Format: iv, 52 leaves
Format: pdf
Publisher: Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University
Publisher: Faculty of Law
Language: English
Rights: Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University

Hits: 2038
Visitors: 3683
Downloads: 3660

Collections

NMMU Department of Mercantile Law

		Thumbnail	File	Description	Size	Format
View Details Download			SOURCEPDF	PDF	428 KB	Adobe Acrobat PDF	View Details Download