Embodied difference in manhood: A sociological analysis of the intersection of visible physical impairments and manhood among Xhosa men in the Eastern Cape

Sipungu, Thoko Andy

Title: Embodied difference in manhood: A sociological analysis of the intersection of visible physical impairments and manhood among Xhosa men in the Eastern Cape
Creator: Sipungu, Thoko Andy
Subject: Masculinity South Africa Eastern Cape
Subject: Sex role South Africa Eastern Cape
Subject: Sex role Psychological aspects
Subject: Men with disabilities South Africa Eastern Cape
Subject: People with disabilities Social conditions
Subject: Xhosa (African people) South Africa Eastern Cape Social life and customs
Subject: Male domination (Social structure) South Africa Eastern Cape
Subject: Circumcision Social aspects South Africa Eastern Cape
Date Issued: 2021-10-29
Date: 2021-10-29
Type: Doctoral theses
Type: text
Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/191658
Identifier: vital:45145
Identifier: 10.21504/10962/191658
Description: In this thesis, I outline possible answers to the question of what it means to be a Xhosa man living with a visible physical impairment. Drawing on 17 one-on-one in-depth interviews and through an interpretive phenomenological thematic analysis, this thesis explores the intersection of physical disabilities and manhood masculinity in Xhosa men in selected rural areas in the Eastern Cape, South Africa. The intention for this study is to better our understanding concerning the creation, negotiation, maintenance, and recreation of manhood identities by traditionally circumcised Xhosa men in the Eastern Cape who by birth, accident, or illness find themselves at the intersections of masculinity and physical disability. Research notes that the bodies of men with disabilities serve as a continual reminder that they are at odds with the expectations of the dominant manhood cultures. The main argument from this area of research is that men with disabilities are outside the hegemony because they undermine the normative role and shape of the body in Western cultures. However, this line of argumentation stands in sharp contrast to arguments that the hegemony in Xhosa manhood masculinity is primarily and conclusively achieved by having a traditionally circumcised penis without any consideration of the full embodiments of men. Therefore, this study, in the first instance, seeks to bring embodiment into the analyses of manhood by focusing on physical disability amongst traditionally circumcised Xhosa men. Through an embodied theoretical approach to their disabilities that accounts for the corporeal experience of impairment, and theories of masculinity that centre the context, this thesis establishes, in the first instance, the significance of embodiment in doing Xhosa manhood. Concerning the research aims and objectives, this study sheds light on what it means to be a Xhosa man living with visible physical impairment. In this regard, the original findings are classified according to each research aims and objective, as outlined below. Concerning the first research aim, I found that the participants struggle to speak about their bodies outside of physical labour/work despite their impairments. I explain their inability to talk about their disabled bodies by looking at traditional Xhosa initiation as a grantor of equality and sameness. Secondly, I argue that there is a higher premium on social bodies rather than physical bodies in this context, thus their inability to speak about their conditions. Lastly, I make connections between the participants’ inabilities to talk about their bodies and the lasting impact of colonial and apartheid histories. Concerning the second research aim, I explore ways and strategies they employ to respond to and negotiate Xhosa manhood masculinity's dominant cultural demands. In this regard, I note that the participants who acquired their impairments after initiation consider their disability as a second initiation because they see it as having set them back to square one regarding their manhood responsibilities. In contrast, the participants who acquired their disabilities post-initiation saw initiation as a gateway to a more respectable personhood status. I also note that there is an emergence of alternative Xhosa manhood masculinities. Lastly, I also found that contrary to western scholarship on disability and manhood, the participants distinguish between threatened manhood identity versus threatened status as a man. I outline how they arrive at this distinction. In terms of researching the last research aim, this thesis explores how the participants negotiate their ‘embodied difference’ in mundane everyday living. I explore their taken-for-granted routines in doing and being disabled Xhosa men every day. In this regard, this study presents original and interesting findings regarding sex and intimacy, social interactions and sociability, and everyday home living.
Description: Thesis (PhD) -- Faculty of Humanities, Sociology, 2021
Format: computer
Format: online resource
Format: application/pdf
Format: 1 online resource (338 pages)
Format: pdf
Publisher: Rhodes University
Publisher: Faculty of Humanities, Sociology
Language: English
Rights: Sipungu, Thoko Andy
Rights: Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
Rights: Open Access

Hits: 2016
Visitors: 3101
Downloads: 1376

Collections

Sipungu, Thoko (Dr)

Gender Action Forum (GENACT)

RU Department of Sociology

SDG 05. Gender Equality

		Thumbnail	File	Description	Size	Format
View Details Download			SOURCE1	SIPUNGU-PHD-TR21-327.pdf	2 MB	Adobe Acrobat PDF	View Details Download