The role of open government data in the repurposing of land administration in postapartheid South Africa : an exploration

Manona, Siyabulela Sobantu

Title: The role of open government data in the repurposing of land administration in postapartheid South Africa : an exploration
Creator: Manona, Siyabulela Sobantu
Subject: Transparency in government -- South Africa
Subject: Land reform -- South Africa
Subject: Qualitative research -- Methodology
Subject: Postcolonialism -- South Africa
Subject: Post-apartheid era -- South Africa
Subject: South Africa -- Economic conditions -- 1991-
Subject: South Africa -- Social conditions -- 1994-
Subject: South Africa -- Politics and government -- 1994-
Subject: Open Government Data (OGD)
Date Issued: 2021-04
Date: 2021-04
Type: thesis
Type: text
Type: Doctoral
Type: PhD
Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/178397
Identifier: vital:42936
Identifier: 10.21504/10962/178397
Description: Almost three decades after the official end of the apartheid, South Africa has been on a sturdy path that is characterised by deepening spatial economic inequalities. A plethora of policy instruments unleashed since 1994 had not only failed to stem the tide of poverty and inequality, but had deepened them. As part of this, South Africa’s most ambitious social engineering programme – land reform -- had disappointing outcomes. Premised on a view that these apartheid continuities were embedded in South Africa’s land administration system – which was incoherent and fragmented and requiring a systemic overhaul -- the study sought to explore the potential role of Open Government Data (OGD) in the repurposing of land administration system in the post-apartheid South Africa. To achieve this goal, the study was guided by the following objectives: to explore the ontology and the state of land governance and administration in the context of the post-apartheid South Africa; to undertake an evaluation or assessment of South Africa’s land data ecosystem; and to explore the potential role of OGD in the repurposing of land administration system in the postapartheid of South Africa. This study was steeped in qualitative research methods, underpinned by primary and secondary literature review. While the study was primarily pitched on a national scale – the combination of the systems and multiple scales approaches – yielded results which dislodges solutions that are required outside of the domain of a single state. This is one glaring example of land governance complexities that straddle beyond national scale – specifically in respect of new policy trajectories on trans-national boundaries and governance of water resources. Based on the holistic ontology of land, this study concludes that land administration and land governance overarching conceptual orientation -- concerned with land use decisions made by humans at various scales from a praxis and policy perspective –constitute two sides of the same coin, the former steeped towards practice and the latter steeped towards policy. Drawing from decolonial theories the study concludes that land does not only have multiple dimensions, but it also has multiple meanings, in a manner that calls for an ontological shift away from the western ontology, towards an inclusive and holistic conceptualisation. Historiography that is anchored in de-colonial thinking of South Africa’s land governance helps us understand how and why – colonial/apartheid norms acrimoniously found their way into the post-apartheid order -- the post-apartheid institutions of modernity rest on the same hierarchies of identities, classification and pathologisation. The study concludes that, while the colonial/apartheid administration may be gone, it’s underlying power matrices continue -- i.e. capitalism/European/patriachal/white – in a manner which explains the continuities of South Africa’s spatial inequalities and the associated economic inequalities. The organising principle for land relations (including opportunities) continues to be underpinned by gender, race and class, in ways that expose the mythical dimensions of the 'post-apartheid' underbelly. While identifying the need for homogenisation and rationalistion of colonial, apartheid and post-apartheid institutions (on a national scale) that is insufficient for the transformation of the colonial situation of what is in essence a part of the global system, the study advocates for the ‘repurposing of land governance and administration’ – underpinned by de-colonial thinking. Repurposing is seen as political imaginary that would entail uncoupling thought processes and praxis from the colonial matrices of power. The study goes on to conclude that there is a definite role for Open Government Data in repurposing of land administration in the post-apartheid South Africa – as a necessary, though in and of it’s own it is an insufficient condition to achieve that ideal -- but presents an opportunity to enhance transdisciplinarity approaches and efficiencies in internal government functioning and evidence-based decision making and policy formulation processes.
Description: Thesis (PhD) -- Faculty of Science, Geography, 2021
Format: computer
Format: online resource
Format: application/pdf
Format: 1 online resource (424 pages)
Format: pdf
Publisher: Rhodes University
Publisher: Faculty of Science, Geography
Language: English
Rights: Manona, Siyabulela Sobantu
Rights: All Rights Reserved

Hits: 7643
Visitors: 8241
Downloads: 888

Collections

RU Department of Geography

		Thumbnail	File	Description	Size	Format
View Details Download			SOURCE1	MANONA-PHD-TR21-138.pdf	2 MB	Adobe Acrobat PDF	View Details Download