Substantive fairness in the context of dismissal for team misconduct
- Authors: Gcayi, Siziwe
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: South Africa -- Labour Relations Act, 1995 , Employees -- Dismissal of -- Law and legislation -- South Africa Labor laws and legislation -- South Africa Unfair labor practices -- South Africa Labor discipline -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/22134 , vital:29852
- Description: Employees have inherent common law duties towards their employers. These duties include: obedience, care, competency and good faith.1 An employee has a duty to act in good faith towards the employer. For purposes of this treatise, focus will be on competency and good faith. Section 188(1) of the Labour Relations Act,2 provides three grounds on which dismissal can be considered to be fair. These grounds are: misconduct, capacity and an employer’s operational requirements. For purposes of this research paper, focus will be on misconduct. Capacity and employer’s operational requirements will not be discussed. For purposes of the present discussion misconduct can be divided into two broad categories namely, individual misconduct and group misconduct. Individual misconduct refers to transgression by a single employee who by his or her conduct violates the company policy or valid rule in the workplace. When the employer contemplates dismissing the employee for misconduct, it has to prove on the balance of probabilities that the employee concerned is guilty of misconduct and that the misconduct concerned justified a dismissal in the sense that it had irretrievably destroyed the requisite trust element in the employment relationship. Group misconduct refers to transgression that has been committed by group of employees. The following forms part of what can be categorised as falling within group misconduct: collective guilt, derivative misconduct, common purpose and team misconduct. Ideally the manner in which group misconduct is dealt with should be different from the way individual misconduct is handled. Individual misconduct refers to a single employee or misconduct of more than one employee who can be isolated and charged/handled as individuals, whereas group misconduct refers to a number of employees, whose conduct has offended the rules of the employer. In respect of group misconduct, the employer does not have to prove individual liability for each of the 1 Module 8 CCMA candidate commissioner notes. 2 66 of 1995. affected employees. An employer may after fulfilling certain requirements penalize them as a group.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
- Authors: Gcayi, Siziwe
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: South Africa -- Labour Relations Act, 1995 , Employees -- Dismissal of -- Law and legislation -- South Africa Labor laws and legislation -- South Africa Unfair labor practices -- South Africa Labor discipline -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/22134 , vital:29852
- Description: Employees have inherent common law duties towards their employers. These duties include: obedience, care, competency and good faith.1 An employee has a duty to act in good faith towards the employer. For purposes of this treatise, focus will be on competency and good faith. Section 188(1) of the Labour Relations Act,2 provides three grounds on which dismissal can be considered to be fair. These grounds are: misconduct, capacity and an employer’s operational requirements. For purposes of this research paper, focus will be on misconduct. Capacity and employer’s operational requirements will not be discussed. For purposes of the present discussion misconduct can be divided into two broad categories namely, individual misconduct and group misconduct. Individual misconduct refers to transgression by a single employee who by his or her conduct violates the company policy or valid rule in the workplace. When the employer contemplates dismissing the employee for misconduct, it has to prove on the balance of probabilities that the employee concerned is guilty of misconduct and that the misconduct concerned justified a dismissal in the sense that it had irretrievably destroyed the requisite trust element in the employment relationship. Group misconduct refers to transgression that has been committed by group of employees. The following forms part of what can be categorised as falling within group misconduct: collective guilt, derivative misconduct, common purpose and team misconduct. Ideally the manner in which group misconduct is dealt with should be different from the way individual misconduct is handled. Individual misconduct refers to a single employee or misconduct of more than one employee who can be isolated and charged/handled as individuals, whereas group misconduct refers to a number of employees, whose conduct has offended the rules of the employer. In respect of group misconduct, the employer does not have to prove individual liability for each of the 1 Module 8 CCMA candidate commissioner notes. 2 66 of 1995. affected employees. An employer may after fulfilling certain requirements penalize them as a group.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
The concept of equal pay for equal work
- Authors: Dorfling, Jennifer Tracey
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Equal pay for equal work -- South Africa , Labor laws and legislation -- South Africa Pay equity -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/22005 , vital:29811
- Description: The elimination of pay discrimination and the introduction of equal remuneration has been advocated internationally since the early 1950s by conventions set out by the International Labour Organisation (ILO). The aim of the International Labour Organisation is to improve working conditions universally, remove discrimination based on gender and establish fair rates of remuneration. In South Africa, regulations were promulgated on 1 August 2014 based on the conventions set out in the ILO, in the newly-amended Employment Equity Act. The amendment to section 6(4) of the Employment Equity Act states that a difference in the conditions between employees employed by the same employer, performing the same or substantially the same work or work of equal value based on any one or more grounds of unfair discrimination listed in subsection (6)1, is unfair discrimination. The introduction of this amendment, therefore, brought about an improved legal framework for employees to bring forth unequal remuneration claims. The doctrine of equal pay for equal work is nuanced owing to the lack of understanding, widespread forms of discrimination as well as interpretation of the law. This is experienced internationally and across many jurisdictions. The jurisdictions focused on in this study include the United States of America, the United Kingdom, India and Australia. The comparative study reviews the current equal pay for equal work law in these jurisdictions, and could prove to be useful guidelines to assist with the expansion of the doctrine within the South African legal context. Pioneer Foods (Pty) Ltd v Workers Against Regression (WAR) and Others was the first case brought forth to the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration since the amendment to the Employment Equity Act. A comprehensive analysis of this case has been set out in the treatise. Finally, the treatise concludes with inadequacies in the current legal framework, recommendations to resolve these inadequacies, the future of equal pay for equal work and proposes practical key learnings for human resources practitioners.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
- Authors: Dorfling, Jennifer Tracey
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Equal pay for equal work -- South Africa , Labor laws and legislation -- South Africa Pay equity -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/22005 , vital:29811
- Description: The elimination of pay discrimination and the introduction of equal remuneration has been advocated internationally since the early 1950s by conventions set out by the International Labour Organisation (ILO). The aim of the International Labour Organisation is to improve working conditions universally, remove discrimination based on gender and establish fair rates of remuneration. In South Africa, regulations were promulgated on 1 August 2014 based on the conventions set out in the ILO, in the newly-amended Employment Equity Act. The amendment to section 6(4) of the Employment Equity Act states that a difference in the conditions between employees employed by the same employer, performing the same or substantially the same work or work of equal value based on any one or more grounds of unfair discrimination listed in subsection (6)1, is unfair discrimination. The introduction of this amendment, therefore, brought about an improved legal framework for employees to bring forth unequal remuneration claims. The doctrine of equal pay for equal work is nuanced owing to the lack of understanding, widespread forms of discrimination as well as interpretation of the law. This is experienced internationally and across many jurisdictions. The jurisdictions focused on in this study include the United States of America, the United Kingdom, India and Australia. The comparative study reviews the current equal pay for equal work law in these jurisdictions, and could prove to be useful guidelines to assist with the expansion of the doctrine within the South African legal context. Pioneer Foods (Pty) Ltd v Workers Against Regression (WAR) and Others was the first case brought forth to the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration since the amendment to the Employment Equity Act. A comprehensive analysis of this case has been set out in the treatise. Finally, the treatise concludes with inadequacies in the current legal framework, recommendations to resolve these inadequacies, the future of equal pay for equal work and proposes practical key learnings for human resources practitioners.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
The criminalization of consensual sexual acts between children
- Authors: Grootboom, Lance Patrick
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Sex crimes -- South Africa , Children -- Legal status, laws, etc -- South Africa , South Africa -- Children's Act, 2005
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/30082 , vital:30823
- Description: Sections 15 and 16 of the Criminal Law Sexual Offences and Related Matters Act (hereinafter referred to as “SORMA”) regulated consensual sexual acts between children. Both these sections criminalised consensual sexual acts between children. Section 15 of SORMA deals with consensual sexual penetration with children 12 years old but under the age of 16 years and section 16 deals with acts of consensual sexual violation with children 12 years of age but under the age of 16. The aim of these two sections was to protect children from undue influence relating to sexual engagement with adults or significantly older children. A number of child organisations criticised sections 15 and 16 on grounds that it is not abnormal for adolescents in the age group 12 to 16 years to experiment with sex and that such conduct are developmentally significant and normative. In the Teddy Bear Clinic and Rapcan v Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development1 (hereinafter referred to as the Teddy Bear case), the constitutionality of sections 15 and 16 of SORMA were challenged in the Constitutional Court. The Constitutional Court held that both sections were unconstitutional and ruled that these sections violated childrens’ right to human dignity, privacy and the best interest of the child principle. The Constitutional Court suspended the declaration of invalidity for a period of 18 months in order to give Parliament an opportunity to remedy the defects in SORMA. On 3 July 2015 the Criminal Law Sexual Offences and Related Matters Amendment, Amendment 5 of 2015, came into operation and amended section 15 and 16 by decriminalising sexual acts between children aged between 12 to 15 years. This research evaluates the arguments and effects of the Teddy Bear case with reference to section 15 and 16 of SORMA and provides an analysis of the current amendments in the Amendment Act 5 2015, with specific reference to its impact on consensual sexual acts between children.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
- Authors: Grootboom, Lance Patrick
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Sex crimes -- South Africa , Children -- Legal status, laws, etc -- South Africa , South Africa -- Children's Act, 2005
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/30082 , vital:30823
- Description: Sections 15 and 16 of the Criminal Law Sexual Offences and Related Matters Act (hereinafter referred to as “SORMA”) regulated consensual sexual acts between children. Both these sections criminalised consensual sexual acts between children. Section 15 of SORMA deals with consensual sexual penetration with children 12 years old but under the age of 16 years and section 16 deals with acts of consensual sexual violation with children 12 years of age but under the age of 16. The aim of these two sections was to protect children from undue influence relating to sexual engagement with adults or significantly older children. A number of child organisations criticised sections 15 and 16 on grounds that it is not abnormal for adolescents in the age group 12 to 16 years to experiment with sex and that such conduct are developmentally significant and normative. In the Teddy Bear Clinic and Rapcan v Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development1 (hereinafter referred to as the Teddy Bear case), the constitutionality of sections 15 and 16 of SORMA were challenged in the Constitutional Court. The Constitutional Court held that both sections were unconstitutional and ruled that these sections violated childrens’ right to human dignity, privacy and the best interest of the child principle. The Constitutional Court suspended the declaration of invalidity for a period of 18 months in order to give Parliament an opportunity to remedy the defects in SORMA. On 3 July 2015 the Criminal Law Sexual Offences and Related Matters Amendment, Amendment 5 of 2015, came into operation and amended section 15 and 16 by decriminalising sexual acts between children aged between 12 to 15 years. This research evaluates the arguments and effects of the Teddy Bear case with reference to section 15 and 16 of SORMA and provides an analysis of the current amendments in the Amendment Act 5 2015, with specific reference to its impact on consensual sexual acts between children.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
The criminalization of HIV and the significance of knowledge: a comparative study
- Authors: Du Toit, Michelle Christine
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: AIDS (Disease) -- Law and legislation -- South Africa , HIV infections -- Law and legislation -- South Africa Criminal law -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/29915 , vital:30793
- Description: Throughout history, epidemics have been endemic to the human experience.1 Medical epidemics can cause both fear and panic among citizens around the globe,2 as can be evidenced by the approaches taken for venereal disease in the past and the Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) in the present. Legal intervention for HIV and other sexually transmitted infections demonstrate how criminalization can be used as a tool to reinforce existing stigmas that separate the sick from the healthy by establishing a moral link between sickness and unlawfulness, especially in matters where sexual conduct is a factor.3 The spheres of public health and criminal law are both aimed at the protection of public welfare and safety in their attempt to neutralize harmful elements in society, whether such harm is evidenced by a disease-causing biological agent or the reckless conduct of individuals.4 The enquiry into the suitability of criminal law as a method of addressing the problem of HIV transmission was necessitated by an awareness of scientific and medical progress in HIV treatment. Currently, criminal law is applied in dealing with HIV transmission in South Africa, and little cognisance is taken of scientific and medical knowledge. South Africa has endorsed the recommendations made by the United Nations to utilise existing criminal laws in the event that it needs to be applied to cases of HIV transmission.5 This study acknowledges the application of criminal laws where HIV transmission occurs as a result of the accused person’s intentional act or omission. The law applicable to HIV transmission in South Africa and certain states in the United States of America (United States) is discussed. The study serves to indicate that, whether general or HIV-specific criminal law is imposed, criminal laws cannot contain HIV transmission, but only serve to particularly address harm suffered.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
- Authors: Du Toit, Michelle Christine
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: AIDS (Disease) -- Law and legislation -- South Africa , HIV infections -- Law and legislation -- South Africa Criminal law -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/29915 , vital:30793
- Description: Throughout history, epidemics have been endemic to the human experience.1 Medical epidemics can cause both fear and panic among citizens around the globe,2 as can be evidenced by the approaches taken for venereal disease in the past and the Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) in the present. Legal intervention for HIV and other sexually transmitted infections demonstrate how criminalization can be used as a tool to reinforce existing stigmas that separate the sick from the healthy by establishing a moral link between sickness and unlawfulness, especially in matters where sexual conduct is a factor.3 The spheres of public health and criminal law are both aimed at the protection of public welfare and safety in their attempt to neutralize harmful elements in society, whether such harm is evidenced by a disease-causing biological agent or the reckless conduct of individuals.4 The enquiry into the suitability of criminal law as a method of addressing the problem of HIV transmission was necessitated by an awareness of scientific and medical progress in HIV treatment. Currently, criminal law is applied in dealing with HIV transmission in South Africa, and little cognisance is taken of scientific and medical knowledge. South Africa has endorsed the recommendations made by the United Nations to utilise existing criminal laws in the event that it needs to be applied to cases of HIV transmission.5 This study acknowledges the application of criminal laws where HIV transmission occurs as a result of the accused person’s intentional act or omission. The law applicable to HIV transmission in South Africa and certain states in the United States of America (United States) is discussed. The study serves to indicate that, whether general or HIV-specific criminal law is imposed, criminal laws cannot contain HIV transmission, but only serve to particularly address harm suffered.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
The customary law practice of ukuthwala – an antithesis in the South African constitutional order
- Jokani, Mkhuseli Christopher
- Authors: Jokani, Mkhuseli Christopher
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Customary law -- South Africa , Culture -- Legal status, laws, etc -- South Africa Forced marriage -- Legal status, laws, etc -- South Africa Teenage marriage -- South Africa -- Eastern Cape Xhosa (African people) -- Law and legislation -- Social life and customs
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Doctoral , LLD
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/22474 , vital:29973
- Description: The concept of ukuthwala is an age-old customary marriage practice prevalent amongst the Nguni speaking tribes of South Africa. It is a practice whereby, preliminary to a customary marriage, a young man, by force, takes a girl to his home. The SABC and E-tv evening television news coverage of 15th March 2009 reported the prevalence of forced and child marriages of young girls with elderly men in the East Pondoland of the Eastern Cape. The question arose as to whether the custom of ukuthwala could be justified as a legitimate cultural practice in the context of a modern constitutional democracy because some view it as an outdated customary practice that targets girl children, while others view it as a legitimate cultural practice. Since ukuthwala cannot be treated as a unitary phenomenon, variants of the practice must be distinguished. The thesis reveals that there are three variants of ukuthwala, which are ukuthwala ngemvumelwano, ukuthwala kobolawu and ukuthwala okungenamvumelwano. The thesis concludes by drawing a distinction between ukuthwala, forced marriage and child marriage. It proposes that ukuthwala in its traditional form is not synonymous with forced marriage and child marriage. The thesis poses the following main legal questions, namely: does the South African criminal jurisprudence criminalise ukuthwala, and if so, on what charges are perpetrators tried; and how is the inherent conflict between the customary law practice of ukuthwala and the Bill of Rights enshrined in the Constitution, resolved? The thesis responds to these questions as follows. Firstly, it is suggested that ukuthwala in itself is not a formally defined crime, but a customary law practice resorted to by the prospective suitor to force the parents of the young woman into marriage negotiations. However, in recent times the practice has been abused and distorted which borders on the commission of a criminal offence and the violation of the young woman’s human rights. The criminal offences that are committed because of the distorted form of ukuthwala are both in terms of the common and statutory laws of South Africa. The thesis suggests that those found guilty of committing a crime under the pretext of customary law practice of ukuthwala should be punished. South Africa has a number of statutory as well as common law provisions, which can be used to prosecute those found to have committed offences. South Africa does not need to outlaw and criminalise ukuthwala in its entirety but does need to distinguish between the distorted and the traditional forms of ukuthwala. The thesis responds to the second main question as follows. Firstly, the violation of the young woman’s human rights brings to the fore a conflict between the customary law practice of ukuthwala and the Bill of Rights enshrined in the Constitution. The thesis makes a distinction between the three variants of ukuthwala customary practices and concludes that ukuthwala ngemvumelwano is the most acceptable form because it takes place when there is mutual consent between parties. It further proposes that the positive elements within the customary law practice of ukuthwala must be developed and promoted provided that they are consistent with the provisions of the Constitution. However, the negative elements that conflict with provisions of the Constitution should be done away with. The thesis suggests that the latter approach is important to addressing the conflict between ukuthwala customary practice and the Bill of Rights. The thesis concludes by suggesting that the distorted form of subjecting young women and girl children into forced marriages under the pretext of the customary law practice of ukuthwala are unconstitutional and cannot be justified in terms of sections 30 and 31 of the Constitution. Therefore, ukuthwala customary law practice is not free from criticism if one considers the two variants of ukuthwala where there has been no consent from one of the parties concerned. A comparative analysis is undertaken with selected Southern African Development Community countries to establish similarities in practices related to ukuthwala and how the consequent contradictions between customary law and common law have been dealt with. The thesis concludes that ukuthwala is a unique South African customary practice that is different from other customary practices in some selected jurisdictions. Therefore, the comparative analysis has helped in identifying how poverty perpetuates the different but related, customary law practices across the selected jurisdictions. Therefore, in order for Mother Africa to adequately respond to the harmful traditional practices there is a need to address the socio-economic issues particularly in the rural parts of Africa. The harmful traditional practices seem to be more common in the rural parts of the selected jurisdictions rather than in urban and semi-urban areas. The lesson learnt is that social development should have a particular bias towards the rural areas of Africa. The findings, amongst others, are that ukuthwala in its traditional form is a legitimate customary law practice which was often resorted to when obstacles arose in order to force the parents of the young woman to negotiate marriage. Ukuthwala is not synonymous with forced and early marriages. The thesis recommends that South Africa does not need to outlaw ukuthwala despite the fact that it has now been abused and distorted. It is argued that there are sufficient statutory and common laws to respond to the scourge of distorted versions of ukuthwala in South Africa. The thesis recommends that South Africa with its plural legal system should highlight the supremacy of the Constitution aligned with international human rights standards to avoid conflict in legal interpretation and implementation. It is hoped that this will assist in the implementation of the positive aspects of African customary law within the legal system and will remove the negative elements that infringe on the rights of women and children. It is recommended that it would be useful to pursue non-legislative measures to deal comprehensively with the causes of ukuthwala and its consequences by investing in education, training and awareness raising campaigns among sectors of society, most importantly rural people. Education, when employed, should not be an event but a process that will start at school level and extend to post-university. The emphasis should be on the inclusion of gender studies from early grades to undo the mentality of male superiority and entrench an equality attitude between boys and girls from a very early age. The reason for this suggestion is that attitudes manifested in our society always portray girls and women as being weak and therefore not equal to boys and men. It is important to ensure that role-players in the fight against gender-based violence are adequately trained to equip them to handle these cases properly. These role-players include South African Police Service members, National Prosecuting Authority, Judiciary and Non-Governmental Organisations to mitigate secondary victimisation of victims of these distorted cultural practices.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
- Authors: Jokani, Mkhuseli Christopher
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Customary law -- South Africa , Culture -- Legal status, laws, etc -- South Africa Forced marriage -- Legal status, laws, etc -- South Africa Teenage marriage -- South Africa -- Eastern Cape Xhosa (African people) -- Law and legislation -- Social life and customs
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Doctoral , LLD
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/22474 , vital:29973
- Description: The concept of ukuthwala is an age-old customary marriage practice prevalent amongst the Nguni speaking tribes of South Africa. It is a practice whereby, preliminary to a customary marriage, a young man, by force, takes a girl to his home. The SABC and E-tv evening television news coverage of 15th March 2009 reported the prevalence of forced and child marriages of young girls with elderly men in the East Pondoland of the Eastern Cape. The question arose as to whether the custom of ukuthwala could be justified as a legitimate cultural practice in the context of a modern constitutional democracy because some view it as an outdated customary practice that targets girl children, while others view it as a legitimate cultural practice. Since ukuthwala cannot be treated as a unitary phenomenon, variants of the practice must be distinguished. The thesis reveals that there are three variants of ukuthwala, which are ukuthwala ngemvumelwano, ukuthwala kobolawu and ukuthwala okungenamvumelwano. The thesis concludes by drawing a distinction between ukuthwala, forced marriage and child marriage. It proposes that ukuthwala in its traditional form is not synonymous with forced marriage and child marriage. The thesis poses the following main legal questions, namely: does the South African criminal jurisprudence criminalise ukuthwala, and if so, on what charges are perpetrators tried; and how is the inherent conflict between the customary law practice of ukuthwala and the Bill of Rights enshrined in the Constitution, resolved? The thesis responds to these questions as follows. Firstly, it is suggested that ukuthwala in itself is not a formally defined crime, but a customary law practice resorted to by the prospective suitor to force the parents of the young woman into marriage negotiations. However, in recent times the practice has been abused and distorted which borders on the commission of a criminal offence and the violation of the young woman’s human rights. The criminal offences that are committed because of the distorted form of ukuthwala are both in terms of the common and statutory laws of South Africa. The thesis suggests that those found guilty of committing a crime under the pretext of customary law practice of ukuthwala should be punished. South Africa has a number of statutory as well as common law provisions, which can be used to prosecute those found to have committed offences. South Africa does not need to outlaw and criminalise ukuthwala in its entirety but does need to distinguish between the distorted and the traditional forms of ukuthwala. The thesis responds to the second main question as follows. Firstly, the violation of the young woman’s human rights brings to the fore a conflict between the customary law practice of ukuthwala and the Bill of Rights enshrined in the Constitution. The thesis makes a distinction between the three variants of ukuthwala customary practices and concludes that ukuthwala ngemvumelwano is the most acceptable form because it takes place when there is mutual consent between parties. It further proposes that the positive elements within the customary law practice of ukuthwala must be developed and promoted provided that they are consistent with the provisions of the Constitution. However, the negative elements that conflict with provisions of the Constitution should be done away with. The thesis suggests that the latter approach is important to addressing the conflict between ukuthwala customary practice and the Bill of Rights. The thesis concludes by suggesting that the distorted form of subjecting young women and girl children into forced marriages under the pretext of the customary law practice of ukuthwala are unconstitutional and cannot be justified in terms of sections 30 and 31 of the Constitution. Therefore, ukuthwala customary law practice is not free from criticism if one considers the two variants of ukuthwala where there has been no consent from one of the parties concerned. A comparative analysis is undertaken with selected Southern African Development Community countries to establish similarities in practices related to ukuthwala and how the consequent contradictions between customary law and common law have been dealt with. The thesis concludes that ukuthwala is a unique South African customary practice that is different from other customary practices in some selected jurisdictions. Therefore, the comparative analysis has helped in identifying how poverty perpetuates the different but related, customary law practices across the selected jurisdictions. Therefore, in order for Mother Africa to adequately respond to the harmful traditional practices there is a need to address the socio-economic issues particularly in the rural parts of Africa. The harmful traditional practices seem to be more common in the rural parts of the selected jurisdictions rather than in urban and semi-urban areas. The lesson learnt is that social development should have a particular bias towards the rural areas of Africa. The findings, amongst others, are that ukuthwala in its traditional form is a legitimate customary law practice which was often resorted to when obstacles arose in order to force the parents of the young woman to negotiate marriage. Ukuthwala is not synonymous with forced and early marriages. The thesis recommends that South Africa does not need to outlaw ukuthwala despite the fact that it has now been abused and distorted. It is argued that there are sufficient statutory and common laws to respond to the scourge of distorted versions of ukuthwala in South Africa. The thesis recommends that South Africa with its plural legal system should highlight the supremacy of the Constitution aligned with international human rights standards to avoid conflict in legal interpretation and implementation. It is hoped that this will assist in the implementation of the positive aspects of African customary law within the legal system and will remove the negative elements that infringe on the rights of women and children. It is recommended that it would be useful to pursue non-legislative measures to deal comprehensively with the causes of ukuthwala and its consequences by investing in education, training and awareness raising campaigns among sectors of society, most importantly rural people. Education, when employed, should not be an event but a process that will start at school level and extend to post-university. The emphasis should be on the inclusion of gender studies from early grades to undo the mentality of male superiority and entrench an equality attitude between boys and girls from a very early age. The reason for this suggestion is that attitudes manifested in our society always portray girls and women as being weak and therefore not equal to boys and men. It is important to ensure that role-players in the fight against gender-based violence are adequately trained to equip them to handle these cases properly. These role-players include South African Police Service members, National Prosecuting Authority, Judiciary and Non-Governmental Organisations to mitigate secondary victimisation of victims of these distorted cultural practices.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
The effect of the amendments to the labour relations act on collective labour law and proliferation of the unions
- Authors: Galorale, Mompati Jonas
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Collective labor agreements -- South Africa , Labor unions -- Law and legislation -- South Africa Labor laws and legislation -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/30216 , vital:30901
- Description: The Constitution guarantees freedom of association, the right of employees to form and join trade unions and to strike, and the rights of trade unions, employers and employers’ associations to bargaining collectively. Section 23 of the Constitution is even-handed: it confers on “everyone” (including employers) a right to fair labour practices and leaving aside the right to strike, confers identical rights on trade unions and employers’ organisations. It is also important to note that the Constitution seeks to advance principles of equality and human dignity before the law. Section 1 of the Labour Relations Act 65 of 1995 (the LRA) provides that the purpose of the LRA is to advance economic development, social justice, labour peace and democratization of the workplace. When interpreting and applying the LRA and the amendments one must give effect to the primary objects of the LRA in compliance with the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 (the Constitution) and in compliance with ratified Conventions of the International Labour Organisation (the ILO). In terms of section 45 of the Labour Relations Amendment Act 6 of 2014 (the LRAA), the President of the Republic of South Africa declared 1 January 2015 as the effective date for the amendments. Employers had from the 1 January 2015 to comply with the LRAA. The amendments impact on all employees, employers and registered trade unions. The amendments responded to, amongst other things, the increased formalisation of labour and also seeks to ensure that vulnerable groups of employees receive adequate protection. The main purpose for the amendments to section 21 of the LRA is to provide for the organisation of employees engaged by a temporary employment service (TES), to broaden the discretion of commissioners under which organisational rights may be granted, to grant majority rights to most representative unions and to allow a commissioner to grant organisational rights despite a threshold agreement. Collective labour law is also materially effected by these amendments, which are aimed at promoting the inclusion of non-standard employees in the collective bargaining framework and expanding the application of organisational rights. The collective-labour law amendments are the focus of this treatise. This will expand the employee pool in a workplace for purposes of securing organisational rights. The amendments have the effect of creating a more inclusive collective bargaining environment in the workplace. It is hoped that this will lessen the need felt by smaller unions to use industrial action as the only route to secure organisational rights previously intended for more representative unions only. The LRAA made it much easier for unions to obtain organisational rights to sufficiently represented unions who do not have majority representation. A commisioner may in terms section 22 of the amendments extend a collective agreement between a TES and its employees and this agreement may be enforced on the client and vice versa. Trade unions representing the employees of a TES will be in a position to exercise their organisational rights not only at the workplace of the TES, but also at the client’s workplace, despite the employees not being employees of the client. In furtherance of these objectives the LRA1 provides a regulatory framework for collective bargaining and organisational rights – in keeping with international and constitutional obligations. Trade unions are the vehicles for effective collective bargaining, while the LRA unequivocally promotes the policy choice of majoritarianism. The LRA was formulated around the furthering of section 23(5) of the Constitution. What is of significance therefore, is to regulate the framework for collective bargaining, of which the amendments prioritized the provision of legislated organisational rights. In keeping with the constitutional objectives mentioned above, section 21(8)(a)(i) of the LRA directs commissioners, in resolving recognition disputes, to: “seek to minimise the proliferation of trade union representation in a single workplace, and where possible, to encourage a system of a representative trade union in a workplace.”
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
- Authors: Galorale, Mompati Jonas
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Collective labor agreements -- South Africa , Labor unions -- Law and legislation -- South Africa Labor laws and legislation -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/30216 , vital:30901
- Description: The Constitution guarantees freedom of association, the right of employees to form and join trade unions and to strike, and the rights of trade unions, employers and employers’ associations to bargaining collectively. Section 23 of the Constitution is even-handed: it confers on “everyone” (including employers) a right to fair labour practices and leaving aside the right to strike, confers identical rights on trade unions and employers’ organisations. It is also important to note that the Constitution seeks to advance principles of equality and human dignity before the law. Section 1 of the Labour Relations Act 65 of 1995 (the LRA) provides that the purpose of the LRA is to advance economic development, social justice, labour peace and democratization of the workplace. When interpreting and applying the LRA and the amendments one must give effect to the primary objects of the LRA in compliance with the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 (the Constitution) and in compliance with ratified Conventions of the International Labour Organisation (the ILO). In terms of section 45 of the Labour Relations Amendment Act 6 of 2014 (the LRAA), the President of the Republic of South Africa declared 1 January 2015 as the effective date for the amendments. Employers had from the 1 January 2015 to comply with the LRAA. The amendments impact on all employees, employers and registered trade unions. The amendments responded to, amongst other things, the increased formalisation of labour and also seeks to ensure that vulnerable groups of employees receive adequate protection. The main purpose for the amendments to section 21 of the LRA is to provide for the organisation of employees engaged by a temporary employment service (TES), to broaden the discretion of commissioners under which organisational rights may be granted, to grant majority rights to most representative unions and to allow a commissioner to grant organisational rights despite a threshold agreement. Collective labour law is also materially effected by these amendments, which are aimed at promoting the inclusion of non-standard employees in the collective bargaining framework and expanding the application of organisational rights. The collective-labour law amendments are the focus of this treatise. This will expand the employee pool in a workplace for purposes of securing organisational rights. The amendments have the effect of creating a more inclusive collective bargaining environment in the workplace. It is hoped that this will lessen the need felt by smaller unions to use industrial action as the only route to secure organisational rights previously intended for more representative unions only. The LRAA made it much easier for unions to obtain organisational rights to sufficiently represented unions who do not have majority representation. A commisioner may in terms section 22 of the amendments extend a collective agreement between a TES and its employees and this agreement may be enforced on the client and vice versa. Trade unions representing the employees of a TES will be in a position to exercise their organisational rights not only at the workplace of the TES, but also at the client’s workplace, despite the employees not being employees of the client. In furtherance of these objectives the LRA1 provides a regulatory framework for collective bargaining and organisational rights – in keeping with international and constitutional obligations. Trade unions are the vehicles for effective collective bargaining, while the LRA unequivocally promotes the policy choice of majoritarianism. The LRA was formulated around the furthering of section 23(5) of the Constitution. What is of significance therefore, is to regulate the framework for collective bargaining, of which the amendments prioritized the provision of legislated organisational rights. In keeping with the constitutional objectives mentioned above, section 21(8)(a)(i) of the LRA directs commissioners, in resolving recognition disputes, to: “seek to minimise the proliferation of trade union representation in a single workplace, and where possible, to encourage a system of a representative trade union in a workplace.”
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
The effective use of legal protection to combat stigma and discrimination related to HIV and AIDS in a workplace: a case study in kwa Zulu Natal
- Authors: Ndobeni, Zoliswa Nomawesile
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: AIDS (Disease) -- Law and legislation , Medical policy -- legislation & jurisprudence Public health -- legislation & jurisprudence HIV-positive persons -- Employment -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/32804 , vital:32365
- Description: Stigma and discrimination continue to be the leading cause of everyday cases of new HIV/AIDS infections in spite of the current legal and medical interventions available. The purpose of the study is to explore the effective use of legal protection in combating stigma and discrimination related to HIV/AIDS in the workplace. When it comes to fighting discrimination and stigma against people living with HIV/AIDS, it is still a challenge as these aspects prevent people from coming forward for testing and for prevention as well as treatment service. The rationale for conducting the study is to examine the relationship of the human rights as per the Constitution of South Africa and the spread and impact of HIV/AIDS on individuals in the workplace. The study is of significance to conduct as the research will further provide knowledge and awareness to both the employer and employee regarding the legal framework pertaining to HIV/AIDS and perhaps unintentional consequences of the legal framework to both the employer and employee concerning productivity and growth. Various legal frameworks were determined to address HIV pandemic in South Africa which constitutes one of the utmost challenges facing the nation as well as benchmarking international law. The structure and functioning of the workplace is a key possibility to address developmental inequities in South Africa. This includes the development of healthcare centres in the workplace. HIV testing involves a great deal of risks and consequences that may not be apparent to the patient. Hence, informed consent is required. Policies and guidelines have been put in place to protect employees. HIV clinicians now argue that HIV testing should be presented as a routine procedure, to remove social barriers and stigma. The present study recommends various programmes that may assist in minimizing stigma and discrimination of people living with HIV. This stigma prevent persons from testing for HIV status. The study also seeks to evaluate and review current policies concerning HIV/AIDS.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
- Authors: Ndobeni, Zoliswa Nomawesile
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: AIDS (Disease) -- Law and legislation , Medical policy -- legislation & jurisprudence Public health -- legislation & jurisprudence HIV-positive persons -- Employment -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/32804 , vital:32365
- Description: Stigma and discrimination continue to be the leading cause of everyday cases of new HIV/AIDS infections in spite of the current legal and medical interventions available. The purpose of the study is to explore the effective use of legal protection in combating stigma and discrimination related to HIV/AIDS in the workplace. When it comes to fighting discrimination and stigma against people living with HIV/AIDS, it is still a challenge as these aspects prevent people from coming forward for testing and for prevention as well as treatment service. The rationale for conducting the study is to examine the relationship of the human rights as per the Constitution of South Africa and the spread and impact of HIV/AIDS on individuals in the workplace. The study is of significance to conduct as the research will further provide knowledge and awareness to both the employer and employee regarding the legal framework pertaining to HIV/AIDS and perhaps unintentional consequences of the legal framework to both the employer and employee concerning productivity and growth. Various legal frameworks were determined to address HIV pandemic in South Africa which constitutes one of the utmost challenges facing the nation as well as benchmarking international law. The structure and functioning of the workplace is a key possibility to address developmental inequities in South Africa. This includes the development of healthcare centres in the workplace. HIV testing involves a great deal of risks and consequences that may not be apparent to the patient. Hence, informed consent is required. Policies and guidelines have been put in place to protect employees. HIV clinicians now argue that HIV testing should be presented as a routine procedure, to remove social barriers and stigma. The present study recommends various programmes that may assist in minimizing stigma and discrimination of people living with HIV. This stigma prevent persons from testing for HIV status. The study also seeks to evaluate and review current policies concerning HIV/AIDS.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
The legal remedies to protect minors against cyberbullying in South Africa
- Authors: Hlazo, Nonhlanhla Irene
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Cyberbullying -- South Africa , Child pornography -- Law and legislation -- South Africa , Child sexual abuse -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/30271 , vital:30914
- Description: The aim of this research is to investigate the constitutional, common law and legislative remedies available to protect the rights of minors against cyberbullying in South Africa and whether these laws are in line with the relevant international instruments. The study focuses on the protection of the rights of minors online as the most vulnerable group in society. The internet was not originally created to be used by minors, therefore, children are subject to more risks on the internet like cyberbullying. Cyberbullying results in the infringement of the rights to privacy, dignity and reputation among others. There are several remedies available in South African private law to protect the rights of minors. However, the rights of the victim must be balanced against the perpetrator’s right to freedom of expression, taking into consideration the best interests of both children. The remedies available are in line with some international instruments safeguarding human rights but there are a number of weaknesses in relation to the application of these remedies to instances of cyberbullying. For example, an interdict cannot be issued in instances where the cyberbully is anonymous. The current legislative framework, although also in line with relevant international instruments, is not going far enough to protect children against cyberbullying. In addition, the term “cyberbullying” is not specifically defined in any of the Acts, which may create challenges in the prosecution of the crime. Fortunately, there are a number of Bills in the pipeline that aim to address the gaps in the current law. Several provisions of the Bills also correlate with relevant international instruments. However, there is a need to revise the proposed Bills in order to sufficiently protect minors against cyberbulling. This study also proposes recommendations relating to some of the inadequacies of the law in this regard.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
- Authors: Hlazo, Nonhlanhla Irene
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Cyberbullying -- South Africa , Child pornography -- Law and legislation -- South Africa , Child sexual abuse -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/30271 , vital:30914
- Description: The aim of this research is to investigate the constitutional, common law and legislative remedies available to protect the rights of minors against cyberbullying in South Africa and whether these laws are in line with the relevant international instruments. The study focuses on the protection of the rights of minors online as the most vulnerable group in society. The internet was not originally created to be used by minors, therefore, children are subject to more risks on the internet like cyberbullying. Cyberbullying results in the infringement of the rights to privacy, dignity and reputation among others. There are several remedies available in South African private law to protect the rights of minors. However, the rights of the victim must be balanced against the perpetrator’s right to freedom of expression, taking into consideration the best interests of both children. The remedies available are in line with some international instruments safeguarding human rights but there are a number of weaknesses in relation to the application of these remedies to instances of cyberbullying. For example, an interdict cannot be issued in instances where the cyberbully is anonymous. The current legislative framework, although also in line with relevant international instruments, is not going far enough to protect children against cyberbullying. In addition, the term “cyberbullying” is not specifically defined in any of the Acts, which may create challenges in the prosecution of the crime. Fortunately, there are a number of Bills in the pipeline that aim to address the gaps in the current law. Several provisions of the Bills also correlate with relevant international instruments. However, there is a need to revise the proposed Bills in order to sufficiently protect minors against cyberbulling. This study also proposes recommendations relating to some of the inadequacies of the law in this regard.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
The non-restoration of land: scope and ambit of section 34 of the restitution of land rights act
- Authors: Christoffels, Eugene Miles
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Restitution -- South Africa , Land reform -- South Africa Land reform -- Government policy -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/23869 , vital:30636
- Description: The land question is an emotionally-laden issue for all people across the racial divide in South Africa, albeit for different reasons land serves a variety of human needs: it creates a sense of identity, it creates wealth, imbues the owner with human dignity; it is also an axis for social cohesion and it is key to the exercise of economic and political power. South Africa is still in the throes of withdrawal symptoms as a result of a checkered colonial past, when it comes to the issue of the land. Having been dispossessed of their ancestral land by the country’s former colonial rulers, the majority of South Africans now have the yearning that the wrongs of the past be addressed, and that justice be done. Having repealed the Apartheid laws which had provided for the calculated systematic dispossession of the land and rights in land of the majority of citizens of South Africa, was and is not sufficient. The Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, being negotiated Constitution, which is internationally lauded, provides for a three-pronged land reform programme, namely restitution, redistribution and tenure reform. The focus of this dissertation is on the restitution leg and more specifically the issue of non-restoration which is provided for in section 34 of the RLRA 22 of 1994, as amended (the RLRA). Section 34 specifically provides that in some instances, land will not be restored to claimants even though they may satisfy the requirements for a valid claim provided for in section 25(7) of the Constitution and section 2 of the RLRA. It is submitted that it is necessary to acquire an understanding of the requirements for a restitution claim even though the land claimed may be removed from the process before a claim has been finalised, since the claimants will still have to satisfy the abovementioned requirements after a particular parcel of land or right in land has been removed from the process by a court of law. In other words, the court has made an order of non-restoration even before the claim has been finalised. Such an application for non-restoration of the land in question or rights in relation to land, may be brought by any national, provincial or local government body, in terms of section 34(1) of the RLRA, and the court will then grant such application provided the applicant has convinced the court that the two threshold requirements listed in section 34(6) have been satisfied. This dissertation outlines a number of cases which serve as practical examples of how the courts dealt with the threshold requirements contained in section 34(6). Included in this examination is the courts’ interpretation of the concepts “public interest” and “substantial prejudice”, which are contained in the requirements listed in section 34(6). This dissertation furthermore sought to determine whether the courts have adopted a broad or narrow approach to these concepts and whether the approach that the courts have adopted strikes an appropriate balance between the constitutional right to restitution and the goals underlying section 34. What is evident from the research is that, apart from the Constitutional Court in the KwaLindile case, none of the other courts provided a substantive definition of the concept “public interest”, but rather chose to refer to academic writings. It is submitted that the courts by and large appear to overlook the fact that the restitution of land and rights in land and arguably, the restoration of land, are in the public interest. While the courts do acknowledge the claimants’ rights to restitution, they downplay the importance of restoration since they argue that there is only a right to restitution and not a right to restoration, and that claimants can still be offered an alternative remedy in lieu of restoration, and in the process courts are ignorant of the fact that these other remedies do not help to change the skewed racial distribution of land in South Africa. Two factors seem to weigh heavily with the courts in favouring the granting of a section 34 order, it being the development of the land or development potential and the avoidance of the cost of a lengthy trial focusing on the restoration when there is no chance of success. It is submitted that there seems to be an over-emphasis on these factors while ignoring the fact that a person’s house is part of his identity, deserving more protection than other property, such as a shopping centre, which is not constitutive of a person’s identity. This view is espoused by Radin. Dyal-Chand postulates the idea that property is not always exclusive but can be shared. This would mean that when it comes to property like shopping centres, which she regards as quasi-public property, the courts should be more willing to grant restoration orders and thus not be so willing to grant section 34 non-restoration orders. Even though the RLRA, through section 34(5)(c) gives the courts the power to transform our colonial system of property law, it is submitted that they have largely failed to rise to this challenge. There appears to be an unwillingness to make a shift from our Roman-Dutch law past and break with our Eurocentric view of property law.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
- Authors: Christoffels, Eugene Miles
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Restitution -- South Africa , Land reform -- South Africa Land reform -- Government policy -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/23869 , vital:30636
- Description: The land question is an emotionally-laden issue for all people across the racial divide in South Africa, albeit for different reasons land serves a variety of human needs: it creates a sense of identity, it creates wealth, imbues the owner with human dignity; it is also an axis for social cohesion and it is key to the exercise of economic and political power. South Africa is still in the throes of withdrawal symptoms as a result of a checkered colonial past, when it comes to the issue of the land. Having been dispossessed of their ancestral land by the country’s former colonial rulers, the majority of South Africans now have the yearning that the wrongs of the past be addressed, and that justice be done. Having repealed the Apartheid laws which had provided for the calculated systematic dispossession of the land and rights in land of the majority of citizens of South Africa, was and is not sufficient. The Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, being negotiated Constitution, which is internationally lauded, provides for a three-pronged land reform programme, namely restitution, redistribution and tenure reform. The focus of this dissertation is on the restitution leg and more specifically the issue of non-restoration which is provided for in section 34 of the RLRA 22 of 1994, as amended (the RLRA). Section 34 specifically provides that in some instances, land will not be restored to claimants even though they may satisfy the requirements for a valid claim provided for in section 25(7) of the Constitution and section 2 of the RLRA. It is submitted that it is necessary to acquire an understanding of the requirements for a restitution claim even though the land claimed may be removed from the process before a claim has been finalised, since the claimants will still have to satisfy the abovementioned requirements after a particular parcel of land or right in land has been removed from the process by a court of law. In other words, the court has made an order of non-restoration even before the claim has been finalised. Such an application for non-restoration of the land in question or rights in relation to land, may be brought by any national, provincial or local government body, in terms of section 34(1) of the RLRA, and the court will then grant such application provided the applicant has convinced the court that the two threshold requirements listed in section 34(6) have been satisfied. This dissertation outlines a number of cases which serve as practical examples of how the courts dealt with the threshold requirements contained in section 34(6). Included in this examination is the courts’ interpretation of the concepts “public interest” and “substantial prejudice”, which are contained in the requirements listed in section 34(6). This dissertation furthermore sought to determine whether the courts have adopted a broad or narrow approach to these concepts and whether the approach that the courts have adopted strikes an appropriate balance between the constitutional right to restitution and the goals underlying section 34. What is evident from the research is that, apart from the Constitutional Court in the KwaLindile case, none of the other courts provided a substantive definition of the concept “public interest”, but rather chose to refer to academic writings. It is submitted that the courts by and large appear to overlook the fact that the restitution of land and rights in land and arguably, the restoration of land, are in the public interest. While the courts do acknowledge the claimants’ rights to restitution, they downplay the importance of restoration since they argue that there is only a right to restitution and not a right to restoration, and that claimants can still be offered an alternative remedy in lieu of restoration, and in the process courts are ignorant of the fact that these other remedies do not help to change the skewed racial distribution of land in South Africa. Two factors seem to weigh heavily with the courts in favouring the granting of a section 34 order, it being the development of the land or development potential and the avoidance of the cost of a lengthy trial focusing on the restoration when there is no chance of success. It is submitted that there seems to be an over-emphasis on these factors while ignoring the fact that a person’s house is part of his identity, deserving more protection than other property, such as a shopping centre, which is not constitutive of a person’s identity. This view is espoused by Radin. Dyal-Chand postulates the idea that property is not always exclusive but can be shared. This would mean that when it comes to property like shopping centres, which she regards as quasi-public property, the courts should be more willing to grant restoration orders and thus not be so willing to grant section 34 non-restoration orders. Even though the RLRA, through section 34(5)(c) gives the courts the power to transform our colonial system of property law, it is submitted that they have largely failed to rise to this challenge. There appears to be an unwillingness to make a shift from our Roman-Dutch law past and break with our Eurocentric view of property law.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
The praxis of reasonability and onus of proof in tax administration in South Africa
- Authors: Mostert, Tarita
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Tax administration and procedure -- South Africa , Taxation -- Law and legislation -- South Africa Internal revenue law -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/22802 , vital:30091
- Description: The legal principles of reasonableness and the burden of proof date back to ancient times. The first codification of these principles occurred in Roman Law. The Tax Administration Act incorporates these principles in various sections. The purpose of this treatise as formulated in Chapter 1 was to determine whether there is a close connection (in practice) between tax administration (within the context of the Tax Administration Act) and the principles of reasonableness and the burden of proof. SARS acknowledges that the principles of best international practice in tax administration must be taken into account1. These principles include equity, fairness, certainty, simplicity, efficiency and effectiveness. Effective tax administration entails that a balance must be struck between the rights and obligations of the taxpayers and those of SARS2. It is important that the taxpayers and SARS strive to communicate with one another in an efficient and effective manner in order to resolve disputes between them. The treatise followed a logical approach. This entailed that the general interpretation of aspects had to be followed by the tax specific interpretation of the aspects. The general interpretation included an analysis of case law as well as research into the origins of the principles of reasonableness and the burden of proof. Reasonableness and the burden of proof do not require perfection. It is important, however, that assertions must be accompanied by evidence. The quality and quantity of evidence submitted is dependent upon the relevant facts and circumstances of a matter. The facts and circumstances of a matter also constitute determining factors in 1 Draft Explanatory Memorandum on the Draft Tax Administration Bill, 2009 at 1 in 2.5. 2 Ibid in 2.1.evaluating whether the principles of reasonableness and the burden of proof have been applied. The treatise concludes that increased efforts are necessary in order to ensure that the principles of reasonableness and the burden of proof are adhered to in tax administration. This obligation is not limited to SARS but also includes taxpayers and tax practitioners. This is closely linked to effective and efficient communication.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
- Authors: Mostert, Tarita
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Tax administration and procedure -- South Africa , Taxation -- Law and legislation -- South Africa Internal revenue law -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/22802 , vital:30091
- Description: The legal principles of reasonableness and the burden of proof date back to ancient times. The first codification of these principles occurred in Roman Law. The Tax Administration Act incorporates these principles in various sections. The purpose of this treatise as formulated in Chapter 1 was to determine whether there is a close connection (in practice) between tax administration (within the context of the Tax Administration Act) and the principles of reasonableness and the burden of proof. SARS acknowledges that the principles of best international practice in tax administration must be taken into account1. These principles include equity, fairness, certainty, simplicity, efficiency and effectiveness. Effective tax administration entails that a balance must be struck between the rights and obligations of the taxpayers and those of SARS2. It is important that the taxpayers and SARS strive to communicate with one another in an efficient and effective manner in order to resolve disputes between them. The treatise followed a logical approach. This entailed that the general interpretation of aspects had to be followed by the tax specific interpretation of the aspects. The general interpretation included an analysis of case law as well as research into the origins of the principles of reasonableness and the burden of proof. Reasonableness and the burden of proof do not require perfection. It is important, however, that assertions must be accompanied by evidence. The quality and quantity of evidence submitted is dependent upon the relevant facts and circumstances of a matter. The facts and circumstances of a matter also constitute determining factors in 1 Draft Explanatory Memorandum on the Draft Tax Administration Bill, 2009 at 1 in 2.5. 2 Ibid in 2.1.evaluating whether the principles of reasonableness and the burden of proof have been applied. The treatise concludes that increased efforts are necessary in order to ensure that the principles of reasonableness and the burden of proof are adhered to in tax administration. This obligation is not limited to SARS but also includes taxpayers and tax practitioners. This is closely linked to effective and efficient communication.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
The protection offered in terms of the 2014 labour law amendments to fixed-term Contract and part-time employees
- Authors: Ntsebeza, Uonella
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Labor laws and legislation -- South Africa , Labor contract -- South Africa Employee rights -- South Africa Labor market -- laws and legislation -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/33567 , vital:32888
- Description: Labour law knows that employers are generally in a stronger bargaining position than employees.1Therefore, labour law is largely premised on the idea of protection of the interest of employees. Fixed term employees2 as ‘atypical’3 or ‘conditional’ employees are particularly weak bargaining parties in the employment relationship. It is common practice for employers to treat fixed term and part-time employees differently to their permanent colleagues. Temporary employment relationships are often associated with the withholding of rights and benefits, lack of job security, deprivation of status and poor remuneration. Fixed term employees are also likely to be more exposed to exploitation, particularly those who are not highly skilled. 4In addition, they often do not enjoy trade union protection and are not covered by collective agreements. Most of these workers are unskilled or work in sectors with limited trade union organisation and limited coverage by collective bargaining, leaving them vulnerable to exploitation. Therefore, fixed term employees are more inclined to depend on the statutory protection enacted to ensure basic working conditions. These employees are often not recruited into trade unions due to the precarious or temporary nature of their work fixed term employees are more inclined to depend on statutory protection enacted to ensure basic working conditions.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
- Authors: Ntsebeza, Uonella
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Labor laws and legislation -- South Africa , Labor contract -- South Africa Employee rights -- South Africa Labor market -- laws and legislation -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/33567 , vital:32888
- Description: Labour law knows that employers are generally in a stronger bargaining position than employees.1Therefore, labour law is largely premised on the idea of protection of the interest of employees. Fixed term employees2 as ‘atypical’3 or ‘conditional’ employees are particularly weak bargaining parties in the employment relationship. It is common practice for employers to treat fixed term and part-time employees differently to their permanent colleagues. Temporary employment relationships are often associated with the withholding of rights and benefits, lack of job security, deprivation of status and poor remuneration. Fixed term employees are also likely to be more exposed to exploitation, particularly those who are not highly skilled. 4In addition, they often do not enjoy trade union protection and are not covered by collective agreements. Most of these workers are unskilled or work in sectors with limited trade union organisation and limited coverage by collective bargaining, leaving them vulnerable to exploitation. Therefore, fixed term employees are more inclined to depend on the statutory protection enacted to ensure basic working conditions. These employees are often not recruited into trade unions due to the precarious or temporary nature of their work fixed term employees are more inclined to depend on statutory protection enacted to ensure basic working conditions.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
The regulation of anti-dumping : a critical assessment with a focus on South Africa
- Authors: Chikomo, Unico
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Antidumping duties
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , Law
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10353/10896 , vital:35961
- Description: Economic globalisation entails the integration of national economies into one economy centred upon free International trade and the unrestricted flow of foreign direct investment.1 It has been argued by economists, politicians, business people, lawyers and many others that economic globalisation results in healthy competition amongst producers of goods and technologies around the world. This in turn results in market efficiency, cheaper, high quality goods and the increased spread of technology and wealth amongst countries. International trade aims to increase trade liberalisation, which has been seen to create higher standards of living for people as a result of greater competition amongst producers in different parts of the international globe. However whilst in support of trade liberalisation trade lawyers have warned that International trade must be fair. Unfair trade can take the form of dumping, price fixing, and certain methods of subsidisation. Unfair trade usually has disastrous effects on the domestic markets of importing countries which can result in injury to domestic industry and the national economy. Such injury can be in the form low sales, losses, company closures and retrenchments. As a result of such domestic injury, World Trade Organisation (WTO) law condemns dumping if it causes injury to the domestic industry of the importing country2 and allows importing countries to impose certain measures aimed at protecting themselves against such injury; these measures are called anti-dumping measures. However, WTO member states need to ensure that their anti-dumping frameworks are consistent with WTO norms. The principal objective of this study is to critically assess the existing regulatory framework of anti-dumping in South Africa with a view to identifying shortcomings that may result in the framework being inconsistent with WTO anti-dumping rules. In pursuing that objective, the study explores the norms and standards of the existing WTO regulatory framework on anti-dumping and ascertains the obligations of South Africa with regard to the imposition of anti-dumping measures.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
- Authors: Chikomo, Unico
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Antidumping duties
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , Law
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10353/10896 , vital:35961
- Description: Economic globalisation entails the integration of national economies into one economy centred upon free International trade and the unrestricted flow of foreign direct investment.1 It has been argued by economists, politicians, business people, lawyers and many others that economic globalisation results in healthy competition amongst producers of goods and technologies around the world. This in turn results in market efficiency, cheaper, high quality goods and the increased spread of technology and wealth amongst countries. International trade aims to increase trade liberalisation, which has been seen to create higher standards of living for people as a result of greater competition amongst producers in different parts of the international globe. However whilst in support of trade liberalisation trade lawyers have warned that International trade must be fair. Unfair trade can take the form of dumping, price fixing, and certain methods of subsidisation. Unfair trade usually has disastrous effects on the domestic markets of importing countries which can result in injury to domestic industry and the national economy. Such injury can be in the form low sales, losses, company closures and retrenchments. As a result of such domestic injury, World Trade Organisation (WTO) law condemns dumping if it causes injury to the domestic industry of the importing country2 and allows importing countries to impose certain measures aimed at protecting themselves against such injury; these measures are called anti-dumping measures. However, WTO member states need to ensure that their anti-dumping frameworks are consistent with WTO norms. The principal objective of this study is to critically assess the existing regulatory framework of anti-dumping in South Africa with a view to identifying shortcomings that may result in the framework being inconsistent with WTO anti-dumping rules. In pursuing that objective, the study explores the norms and standards of the existing WTO regulatory framework on anti-dumping and ascertains the obligations of South Africa with regard to the imposition of anti-dumping measures.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
The reliability of firearm identification in South Africa : a comparative perspective
- Authors: Mutsavi, Tanyarara
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Forensic sciences Firearms -- Identification
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , Law
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10353/10850 , vital:35860
- Description: Crime has become a well-known and worrying fact of life in South Africa. It constrains the ability of citizens to participate actively and meaningfully in all spheres of social and economic life. In many cases where a crime is committed, a firearm is involved. In order to fight gun crime there is a need for the perpetrators to be prosecuted. For prosecution to take place, there must be evidence to link the suspects to the committed crime. This is when firearm identification as a form of expert scientific evidence comes into play. This type of evidence links the bullets and cartridges recovered from the crime scene to the suspect.s firearms through the process of matching which is done by using a comparison microscope. Expert scientific evidence like firearm identification evidence, needs to be scientifically reliable because unreliable evidence may lead to the conviction of the innocent and exoneration of the guilty. Case law, authoritative reports and other literature have shown that firearm identification is not scientific and therefore it is not reliable. This is a disturbing position, considering the fact that this type of evidence is still being used in courts and no alternative has been found thus far to replace it. This study therefore proposes some reforms and recommendations which have been registered in authoritative reports which assist South Africa in dealing with firearm identification evidence. To achieve reliability, some writers have suggested that South Africa should adopt the US approach with regard to admissibility where judges play a .gate keeping. role by making sure that expert evidence is reliable before it enters the court. However, this study argues that scientific reliability, in South Africa, should not be a criterion for admissibility, but should rather be a central factor in deciding what weight should be attached to the expert evidence given in a particular case. The reason for this is that, in South Africa, the jury system is not used and therefore the judge does not have to exercise a .gate keeping. role, as he or she will be the final arbiter as to whether the evidence is reliable. In this context, reliability is considered during cross-examination. Cross-examination by the defence is crucial and this study proposes some possible cross-examination questions that can be helpful in testing the reliability of firearm identification evidence.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
- Authors: Mutsavi, Tanyarara
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Forensic sciences Firearms -- Identification
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , Law
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10353/10850 , vital:35860
- Description: Crime has become a well-known and worrying fact of life in South Africa. It constrains the ability of citizens to participate actively and meaningfully in all spheres of social and economic life. In many cases where a crime is committed, a firearm is involved. In order to fight gun crime there is a need for the perpetrators to be prosecuted. For prosecution to take place, there must be evidence to link the suspects to the committed crime. This is when firearm identification as a form of expert scientific evidence comes into play. This type of evidence links the bullets and cartridges recovered from the crime scene to the suspect.s firearms through the process of matching which is done by using a comparison microscope. Expert scientific evidence like firearm identification evidence, needs to be scientifically reliable because unreliable evidence may lead to the conviction of the innocent and exoneration of the guilty. Case law, authoritative reports and other literature have shown that firearm identification is not scientific and therefore it is not reliable. This is a disturbing position, considering the fact that this type of evidence is still being used in courts and no alternative has been found thus far to replace it. This study therefore proposes some reforms and recommendations which have been registered in authoritative reports which assist South Africa in dealing with firearm identification evidence. To achieve reliability, some writers have suggested that South Africa should adopt the US approach with regard to admissibility where judges play a .gate keeping. role by making sure that expert evidence is reliable before it enters the court. However, this study argues that scientific reliability, in South Africa, should not be a criterion for admissibility, but should rather be a central factor in deciding what weight should be attached to the expert evidence given in a particular case. The reason for this is that, in South Africa, the jury system is not used and therefore the judge does not have to exercise a .gate keeping. role, as he or she will be the final arbiter as to whether the evidence is reliable. In this context, reliability is considered during cross-examination. Cross-examination by the defence is crucial and this study proposes some possible cross-examination questions that can be helpful in testing the reliability of firearm identification evidence.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
The return-to-work policy for injured and diseased workers
- Authors: Keti, Nosicelo
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Employees -- Rehabilitation -- South Africa , Labor laws and legislation -- South Africa Workers' compensation Industrial accidents
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/31064 , vital:31307
- Description: Despite measures undertaken by employers in promoting safety in the workplace, employees become injured or diseased due to work related accidents. When an employee sustains a work related injury or disease that results in their short term or prolonged absence from work, it becomes crucial for the employer to return the injured or diseased employee back to work as quickly as possible. Returning employees back to work as early as possible becomes an important factor in reducing worker’s compensation costs. In South Africa, unlike developed countries like the United Kingdom, there is still a lack or absence of rehabilitation, reintegration and RTW programmes. The lack or absence of suitable rehabilitation, reintegration and RTW programmes that not only ensure that an injured or diseased employee is returned to work, but further enable such injured or diseased employee to attain, keep and progress in employment often results in employees becoming dependent on disability grants or social welfare payments. There is recognition that some effort is required to ensure that employees who have been affected by work related injuries or diseases are returned to gainful employment. The Committee of Inquiry into a Comprehensive System of Social Security for South Africa, in 2002, highlighted that “modern social protection policy making is no longer therapeutic but also pre-emptive and restorative or rehabilitative in nature”. The study investigated the need for the South African government and business to adopt and implement programmes or systems that are targeted at correcting or restoring the damage. This can be achieved through retraining, re-skilling and social integration of the injured or diseased employees. The findings indicate that despite recognition by the Compensation of Occupational Injuries and Disease Act (COIDA) of the need to establish and implement appropriate rehabilitation, reintegration and RTW programmes, such programmes have still not been established in South Africa. There are, however, initiatives directed towards the establishment and implementation of these programmes and these are found in the proposed COIDA amendment Bill which prioritises rehabilitation, reintegration and RTW. Proposed in the Bill, is the imposition of incentives for those employers who successfully implement rehabilitation, reintegration and RTW programmes within their workplaces and penalties against those who fail to comply with the provisions of the proposed Bill. Another relief can be seen in the form of the Road Accident Benefit Scheme (RABS) Bill, which will soon replace the Road Accident Fund (RAF). Unlike the RAF, which is primarily concerned about the compensation of road accident victims through lump sum payments, RABS will particularly focus on rehabilitation and vocational training and will offer payments in a structured manner to not only ensure the continual financial support of the accident victims, but further that the proposed scheme remains sustainable in the long term. Further findings are that although the Constitution of the v Republic of South Africa has adopted an international law friendly approach and the Bill of Rights is in support of the implementation of RTW measures, South African law is not aligned to international and regional standards. South Africa has still not ratified international instruments that promote the early return of injured or diseased employees back to work. In conclusion, South Africa needs to adopt and implement rehabilitation, reintegration and RTW measures or programmes for injured or diseased workers in order to address the high unemployment rate, poverty and dependence on State funded social assistance services.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
- Authors: Keti, Nosicelo
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Employees -- Rehabilitation -- South Africa , Labor laws and legislation -- South Africa Workers' compensation Industrial accidents
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/31064 , vital:31307
- Description: Despite measures undertaken by employers in promoting safety in the workplace, employees become injured or diseased due to work related accidents. When an employee sustains a work related injury or disease that results in their short term or prolonged absence from work, it becomes crucial for the employer to return the injured or diseased employee back to work as quickly as possible. Returning employees back to work as early as possible becomes an important factor in reducing worker’s compensation costs. In South Africa, unlike developed countries like the United Kingdom, there is still a lack or absence of rehabilitation, reintegration and RTW programmes. The lack or absence of suitable rehabilitation, reintegration and RTW programmes that not only ensure that an injured or diseased employee is returned to work, but further enable such injured or diseased employee to attain, keep and progress in employment often results in employees becoming dependent on disability grants or social welfare payments. There is recognition that some effort is required to ensure that employees who have been affected by work related injuries or diseases are returned to gainful employment. The Committee of Inquiry into a Comprehensive System of Social Security for South Africa, in 2002, highlighted that “modern social protection policy making is no longer therapeutic but also pre-emptive and restorative or rehabilitative in nature”. The study investigated the need for the South African government and business to adopt and implement programmes or systems that are targeted at correcting or restoring the damage. This can be achieved through retraining, re-skilling and social integration of the injured or diseased employees. The findings indicate that despite recognition by the Compensation of Occupational Injuries and Disease Act (COIDA) of the need to establish and implement appropriate rehabilitation, reintegration and RTW programmes, such programmes have still not been established in South Africa. There are, however, initiatives directed towards the establishment and implementation of these programmes and these are found in the proposed COIDA amendment Bill which prioritises rehabilitation, reintegration and RTW. Proposed in the Bill, is the imposition of incentives for those employers who successfully implement rehabilitation, reintegration and RTW programmes within their workplaces and penalties against those who fail to comply with the provisions of the proposed Bill. Another relief can be seen in the form of the Road Accident Benefit Scheme (RABS) Bill, which will soon replace the Road Accident Fund (RAF). Unlike the RAF, which is primarily concerned about the compensation of road accident victims through lump sum payments, RABS will particularly focus on rehabilitation and vocational training and will offer payments in a structured manner to not only ensure the continual financial support of the accident victims, but further that the proposed scheme remains sustainable in the long term. Further findings are that although the Constitution of the v Republic of South Africa has adopted an international law friendly approach and the Bill of Rights is in support of the implementation of RTW measures, South African law is not aligned to international and regional standards. South Africa has still not ratified international instruments that promote the early return of injured or diseased employees back to work. In conclusion, South Africa needs to adopt and implement rehabilitation, reintegration and RTW measures or programmes for injured or diseased workers in order to address the high unemployment rate, poverty and dependence on State funded social assistance services.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
The right of access to information as a means to empower citizens to participate in democratic processes : a case study of Zwelitsha, King Williams Town
- Authors: Ngcuka, Simtembile
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Freedom of information Freedom of information -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , (MPhil)Human Rights
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10353/10839 , vital:35858
- Description: The Republic of South Africa is embedded from a society that has been beleaguered. Apartheid laws were used to treat people unequally, based on race, gander, ethnic group, background, colour, belief, culture and language. These laws prohibited association of people from different races and groups. The education system was also used to instil inferiority to disadvantaged people. This system promoted a culture of secrecy and unresponsive government. The new Constitution of the Republic of South Africa was adopted in 1996. This Constitution promotes democracy and equality amongst citizens of this country. It was also adopted to bridge injustices of the past. Democracy is about allowing every citizen to participate in the processes which are meant for the development of the country. The new Constitution provided that every citizen is equal; this means every citizen must enjoy equal human Rights. This includes the Right to participate in democratic processes which are taking place. Studies show that the Right of Access to Information empowers people to participate in democratic processes. This study examines the exercise in section 32 of the Republic of South Africa Constitution (1996), by Zwelitsha community as means to empower people in participating in democratic processes taking place in their community. This Right is reinforced by Promotion of Access to Information Act No. 2 of 2000 (PAIA). The research reveals that the community of Zwelitsha is not exercising this Right which often leads to violation of other Rights. The exercise of the Right of Access to Information increases awareness and knowledge of other existing Rights, and how they can be realised and defended. The recommendations in the study underscore the need to promote the Right of Access to Information as a means to empower citizens to participate in the democratic processes in their community. This study will take the community a step closer to reaching equality. It will also educate the community of the need and importance of exercising the Right of Access to Information. It will assist the community to be able to protect other Rights. An informed community is an empowered community that can also hold the state to account.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
- Authors: Ngcuka, Simtembile
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Freedom of information Freedom of information -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , (MPhil)Human Rights
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10353/10839 , vital:35858
- Description: The Republic of South Africa is embedded from a society that has been beleaguered. Apartheid laws were used to treat people unequally, based on race, gander, ethnic group, background, colour, belief, culture and language. These laws prohibited association of people from different races and groups. The education system was also used to instil inferiority to disadvantaged people. This system promoted a culture of secrecy and unresponsive government. The new Constitution of the Republic of South Africa was adopted in 1996. This Constitution promotes democracy and equality amongst citizens of this country. It was also adopted to bridge injustices of the past. Democracy is about allowing every citizen to participate in the processes which are meant for the development of the country. The new Constitution provided that every citizen is equal; this means every citizen must enjoy equal human Rights. This includes the Right to participate in democratic processes which are taking place. Studies show that the Right of Access to Information empowers people to participate in democratic processes. This study examines the exercise in section 32 of the Republic of South Africa Constitution (1996), by Zwelitsha community as means to empower people in participating in democratic processes taking place in their community. This Right is reinforced by Promotion of Access to Information Act No. 2 of 2000 (PAIA). The research reveals that the community of Zwelitsha is not exercising this Right which often leads to violation of other Rights. The exercise of the Right of Access to Information increases awareness and knowledge of other existing Rights, and how they can be realised and defended. The recommendations in the study underscore the need to promote the Right of Access to Information as a means to empower citizens to participate in the democratic processes in their community. This study will take the community a step closer to reaching equality. It will also educate the community of the need and importance of exercising the Right of Access to Information. It will assist the community to be able to protect other Rights. An informed community is an empowered community that can also hold the state to account.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
The role of the CCMA and bargaining councils in labour dispute resolution
- Authors: Mkalipi, Thembinkosi
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: South Africa -- Commission for Conciliation, Mediation, and Arbitration , Dispute resolution (Law) -- South Africa Arbitration, Industrial -- South Africa Collective bargaining -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/32182 , vital:31977
- Description: A feature of collective bargaining is that it has a habit of ending in deadlock. However, in the event of a dispute, an aggrieved party is not free to call an immediate strike or lockout. The Labour Relations Act of 1956 and the Labour Relations Act of 1995 (“the LRA”) provided for a strict procedure to be followed in an event of a dispute. The law before 1995 regarded industrial action in the case of a dispute that did not follow the procedure as an illegal act attracting criminal sanction. The law then distinguished between a dispute of right and a dispute of interest. Like many countries, South Africa, has a very violent history regarding the resolution of labour disputes. This is illustrated by the force and brutality that was used to solve the 1913 white miners’ strike after martial law was declared. The reaction of the employers and the state was more brutal. The same violence and brutality were applied in the 1914 railway-workers strike and the 1946 African workers strike. The most important purpose of labour law is to ensure labour peace will prevail in the labour market and to regulate relations between employer and employee. Labour peace ensures that the economy functions effectively and if this happens, society at large benefits greatly. In Chapter 1 of the LRA one of the purposes of the LRA is stated as: “the effective resolution of labour disputes.” This section is intended to give effect section 23(1) of the Constitution, which provide that, ‘‘everyone has the right to fair labour practices’’1. This treatise will analyse the role of the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (the CCMA) in dispute resolution; its functions and jurisdiction, ensure labour peace and whether the dispute resolution system provided in the law and implemented by the different dispute resolution institutions have succeeded to advance Constitution of the Republic of South Africa Act 108 [1996]. Economic development, social justice, labour peace and the democratisation of the workplace to fulfil the purpose of the LRA. Under the previous Labour Relations Act2 (the “1956 LRA”) disputes were resolved through three main institutions namely, Conciliation Boards, Industrial Councils and the Industrial Court3. A Conciliation Board was on ad hoc - body established by the Minister of Manpower on application by any one of the parties in dispute. There was no requirement for an agreement between the disputing parties to apply for the establishment of a Conciliation Board. Either party could approach the Minister for its establishment. This application could be made on the workers side by one or more registered trade unions, one or more employees, or one or more registered trade unions. On the employer’s side, the application can be made by one or more registered employers’ organisations or, one or more employers.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
- Authors: Mkalipi, Thembinkosi
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: South Africa -- Commission for Conciliation, Mediation, and Arbitration , Dispute resolution (Law) -- South Africa Arbitration, Industrial -- South Africa Collective bargaining -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/32182 , vital:31977
- Description: A feature of collective bargaining is that it has a habit of ending in deadlock. However, in the event of a dispute, an aggrieved party is not free to call an immediate strike or lockout. The Labour Relations Act of 1956 and the Labour Relations Act of 1995 (“the LRA”) provided for a strict procedure to be followed in an event of a dispute. The law before 1995 regarded industrial action in the case of a dispute that did not follow the procedure as an illegal act attracting criminal sanction. The law then distinguished between a dispute of right and a dispute of interest. Like many countries, South Africa, has a very violent history regarding the resolution of labour disputes. This is illustrated by the force and brutality that was used to solve the 1913 white miners’ strike after martial law was declared. The reaction of the employers and the state was more brutal. The same violence and brutality were applied in the 1914 railway-workers strike and the 1946 African workers strike. The most important purpose of labour law is to ensure labour peace will prevail in the labour market and to regulate relations between employer and employee. Labour peace ensures that the economy functions effectively and if this happens, society at large benefits greatly. In Chapter 1 of the LRA one of the purposes of the LRA is stated as: “the effective resolution of labour disputes.” This section is intended to give effect section 23(1) of the Constitution, which provide that, ‘‘everyone has the right to fair labour practices’’1. This treatise will analyse the role of the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (the CCMA) in dispute resolution; its functions and jurisdiction, ensure labour peace and whether the dispute resolution system provided in the law and implemented by the different dispute resolution institutions have succeeded to advance Constitution of the Republic of South Africa Act 108 [1996]. Economic development, social justice, labour peace and the democratisation of the workplace to fulfil the purpose of the LRA. Under the previous Labour Relations Act2 (the “1956 LRA”) disputes were resolved through three main institutions namely, Conciliation Boards, Industrial Councils and the Industrial Court3. A Conciliation Board was on ad hoc - body established by the Minister of Manpower on application by any one of the parties in dispute. There was no requirement for an agreement between the disputing parties to apply for the establishment of a Conciliation Board. Either party could approach the Minister for its establishment. This application could be made on the workers side by one or more registered trade unions, one or more employees, or one or more registered trade unions. On the employer’s side, the application can be made by one or more registered employers’ organisations or, one or more employers.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
The scope of environmental protection under the legal framework of the World Trade Organisation : an evaluation of the issues and implications for developing countries
- Authors: Umenze, Nnamdi Stanislaus
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Environmental protection -- Developing countries Environmental law -- Developing countries
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10353/10802 , vital:35762
- Description: Over the years, the extent to which the legal framework of the World Trade Organisation (WTO) makes provision for environmental protection has been a major issue within the organisation. While trade liberalisation and environmental protection are fundamental objectives of the WTO to be pursued in line with the sustainable development goals as enshrined in the Preamble of the Marrakesh Agreement, the organisation does not have a specific agreement on the environment. Moreover, efforts by the member states of the WTO to reform the environmental protection regime of the global trading system have achieved little. Nevertheless, under the current legal framework of the WTO, members are allowed, subject to a number of conditions, to adopt trade-related measures aimed at protecting the environment. Employing documentary research methodology, this study critically evaluates the relationship between trade and the environment, the provisions made for environmental protection in selected WTO agreements and the extent to which trade-related environmental protection measures are permissible under the legal framework of the WTO. It also evaluates the implications of unilateral and the Multilateral Environmental Agreements (MEA)-based environmental trade measures as well as the possibility of a clash of policy objectives between the WTO Agreements and the MEAs, given that some of the MEAs contain environmental trade measures prohibited by the WTO free trade rules. The findings made in this study suggest that states generally prefer to enforce unilateral environmental trade measures against foreign goods. This has allowed states, in some instances, to hide under the guise of environmental protection to pursue protectionist’s interests, eco-imperialism, etc., leading to the trade and environment-related disputes at the WTO. Moreover, the WTO is made up of member states that are at different levels of development and possess different environmental protection standards. Hence, there is concern from developing countries, on the one hand, that their economic interests are being frustrated by the stringent application of unilateral environmental trade measures in the developed countries, and, on the other hand, that the environmental burden of international trade is being shifted to the developing countries as the developed countries tighten their environmental standards. The study concludes that the environmental protection regime of the WTO as it stands is not adequate to guarantee the balance of trade and environmental protection objectives as well as the balance of interests between the developed and developing countries. The study, therefore, recommends reform in the environmental protection regime of the WTO to ensure that the environmental protection measures are adequately provided for and that balance of interests between the developed and developing countries is maintained in order to ensure sustainable global trade. It further recommends that a mutually reinforcing relationship should be established between the WTO and the MEAs to avoid a possible clash of policy objectives.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
- Authors: Umenze, Nnamdi Stanislaus
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Environmental protection -- Developing countries Environmental law -- Developing countries
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10353/10802 , vital:35762
- Description: Over the years, the extent to which the legal framework of the World Trade Organisation (WTO) makes provision for environmental protection has been a major issue within the organisation. While trade liberalisation and environmental protection are fundamental objectives of the WTO to be pursued in line with the sustainable development goals as enshrined in the Preamble of the Marrakesh Agreement, the organisation does not have a specific agreement on the environment. Moreover, efforts by the member states of the WTO to reform the environmental protection regime of the global trading system have achieved little. Nevertheless, under the current legal framework of the WTO, members are allowed, subject to a number of conditions, to adopt trade-related measures aimed at protecting the environment. Employing documentary research methodology, this study critically evaluates the relationship between trade and the environment, the provisions made for environmental protection in selected WTO agreements and the extent to which trade-related environmental protection measures are permissible under the legal framework of the WTO. It also evaluates the implications of unilateral and the Multilateral Environmental Agreements (MEA)-based environmental trade measures as well as the possibility of a clash of policy objectives between the WTO Agreements and the MEAs, given that some of the MEAs contain environmental trade measures prohibited by the WTO free trade rules. The findings made in this study suggest that states generally prefer to enforce unilateral environmental trade measures against foreign goods. This has allowed states, in some instances, to hide under the guise of environmental protection to pursue protectionist’s interests, eco-imperialism, etc., leading to the trade and environment-related disputes at the WTO. Moreover, the WTO is made up of member states that are at different levels of development and possess different environmental protection standards. Hence, there is concern from developing countries, on the one hand, that their economic interests are being frustrated by the stringent application of unilateral environmental trade measures in the developed countries, and, on the other hand, that the environmental burden of international trade is being shifted to the developing countries as the developed countries tighten their environmental standards. The study concludes that the environmental protection regime of the WTO as it stands is not adequate to guarantee the balance of trade and environmental protection objectives as well as the balance of interests between the developed and developing countries. The study, therefore, recommends reform in the environmental protection regime of the WTO to ensure that the environmental protection measures are adequately provided for and that balance of interests between the developed and developing countries is maintained in order to ensure sustainable global trade. It further recommends that a mutually reinforcing relationship should be established between the WTO and the MEAs to avoid a possible clash of policy objectives.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
The unfair labour practice relating to suspension
- Authors: Moela, Matlose Phineas
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Unfair labor practices -- South Africa , Labor laws and legislation -- South Africa Labor policy -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/23038 , vital:30398
- Description: This treatise considers unfair-labour- practice relating to suspensions in the workplace. Furthermore the treatise outlines the legal framework relating to suspensions in the workplace. As I explore this fundamental issues of the law, the fairness relating to suspension will be examined. Some recommendations are also made as to how departments and organisations must develop guidelines and policies which are legally sound to deal with suspension in the workplace. Employees often challenge the fairness of their suspension in the workplace. These challenges are based on a number of things, including failure to provide an employee to make representations, failure to comply with policies regulating suspensions in the workplace, suspension without pay, prolonged suspensions, etc. The treatise therefore also consider these challenges as well as the recourse available to employees. The treatise commences with the legal framework and principles contained in the Labour Relations Act, 66 of 1995 (hereinafter referred to as the LRA) applicable to suspensions. The treatise then considers other legislation and recent developments in both the public and private sector. The study concludes with remedies available to employees in instances where an unfair-labour-practice relating to suspension has been found to be committed by an employer during the suspension process.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
- Authors: Moela, Matlose Phineas
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Unfair labor practices -- South Africa , Labor laws and legislation -- South Africa Labor policy -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , LLM
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/23038 , vital:30398
- Description: This treatise considers unfair-labour- practice relating to suspensions in the workplace. Furthermore the treatise outlines the legal framework relating to suspensions in the workplace. As I explore this fundamental issues of the law, the fairness relating to suspension will be examined. Some recommendations are also made as to how departments and organisations must develop guidelines and policies which are legally sound to deal with suspension in the workplace. Employees often challenge the fairness of their suspension in the workplace. These challenges are based on a number of things, including failure to provide an employee to make representations, failure to comply with policies regulating suspensions in the workplace, suspension without pay, prolonged suspensions, etc. The treatise therefore also consider these challenges as well as the recourse available to employees. The treatise commences with the legal framework and principles contained in the Labour Relations Act, 66 of 1995 (hereinafter referred to as the LRA) applicable to suspensions. The treatise then considers other legislation and recent developments in both the public and private sector. The study concludes with remedies available to employees in instances where an unfair-labour-practice relating to suspension has been found to be committed by an employer during the suspension process.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
The use of alternative dispute resolution mechanisms in labour relations in the workplace in South Africa
- Authors: Rwodzi, Night Tafadzwa
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Dispute resolution (Law) -- South Africa Mediation and conciliation, Industrial -- South Africa Industrial relations -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , Law
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10353/10907 , vital:35962
- Description: Disputes are part and parcel of human nature and always manifest everywhereincluding the employment arena. It is this inevitability of disputes that warrantsmeasures to be in place so as to effectively and without delay, resolve them in order to realise industrial peace. This study is prompted by the way industrial disputes have been handled in the past and the contemporary era. South African legal system provides Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) mechanisms to the use of adjudication by the ordinary courts in resolving workplace disputes. However, a set of methods made up of conciliation, mediation and arbitration have not been effective in resolving labour disputes owing to a variety of factors. Failure to provide a speedy resolution of disputes, large number of referrals to the Commissioner for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA) and a large number of review applications lodged at the Labour Courts are some of the contributory factors that delay matters in bringing to finality. It is therefore the aim of this study, to proffer plausible recommendations that intends to cure and provide a silver bullet to the lacuna which exists in the current labour dispute system. To achieve the above stipulated aim, a general background of the study, accompanied by the chronicles of dispute resolution statutes and mechanisms is deliberated. Thereafter, South African compliance with International Labour Organisation (ILO) Conventions is discussed to assess the efficacy of labour dispute mechanisms. A critical analyses of the effectiveness of ADR within the scope of Labour Relations Act (LRA) 66 of 1995 will then follow. Although there are some limitations to this study, it should be noted that relevant legislation passed by parliament, cases, together with international and regional conventions ratified by the government, scholarly articles, journals and books are used to strengthen arguments and provide guidance in achieving the aims and objectives of the study.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
- Authors: Rwodzi, Night Tafadzwa
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Dispute resolution (Law) -- South Africa Mediation and conciliation, Industrial -- South Africa Industrial relations -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , Law
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10353/10907 , vital:35962
- Description: Disputes are part and parcel of human nature and always manifest everywhereincluding the employment arena. It is this inevitability of disputes that warrantsmeasures to be in place so as to effectively and without delay, resolve them in order to realise industrial peace. This study is prompted by the way industrial disputes have been handled in the past and the contemporary era. South African legal system provides Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) mechanisms to the use of adjudication by the ordinary courts in resolving workplace disputes. However, a set of methods made up of conciliation, mediation and arbitration have not been effective in resolving labour disputes owing to a variety of factors. Failure to provide a speedy resolution of disputes, large number of referrals to the Commissioner for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA) and a large number of review applications lodged at the Labour Courts are some of the contributory factors that delay matters in bringing to finality. It is therefore the aim of this study, to proffer plausible recommendations that intends to cure and provide a silver bullet to the lacuna which exists in the current labour dispute system. To achieve the above stipulated aim, a general background of the study, accompanied by the chronicles of dispute resolution statutes and mechanisms is deliberated. Thereafter, South African compliance with International Labour Organisation (ILO) Conventions is discussed to assess the efficacy of labour dispute mechanisms. A critical analyses of the effectiveness of ADR within the scope of Labour Relations Act (LRA) 66 of 1995 will then follow. Although there are some limitations to this study, it should be noted that relevant legislation passed by parliament, cases, together with international and regional conventions ratified by the government, scholarly articles, journals and books are used to strengthen arguments and provide guidance in achieving the aims and objectives of the study.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
Towards unmasking the true employee in South Africa’s contemporary work environment: the perennial problem of labour law
- Authors: Maloka, Tumo Charles
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Labor laws and legislation
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Doctoral , LLD
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10353/16874 , vital:40781
- Description: The enormously intricate task of unmasking the true employee in contemporary work environment reveals the dilemmas and complexities embedded in the beguilingly simple but intractable question: who is an employee? The hallmarks of a true employee are shaded in modern work environment given that the actual differences between the categories of “employee” and “independent contractor” are diminishing. The conception of self-employment that links being self-employed inextricably with entrepreneurship, ownership, and autonomy has more to do with ideology than reality. In addressing the opacities of form engendered by “Work on demand via app” and the “Uberisation of work”, the study also attends to the significant and neglected component of labour law’s traditional dilemma. Put simply, how the law identifies an “employer” as a counterparty with an “employee”. Certain features of modern business organisation such as vertical disintegration of production, and their link to the rise of precarious employment underscore the extent to which the concept of employer plays a central role in defining the contours of labour protection. The problems of precarity are deep-seated, long-term and even escalating, especially in compelled and dependent self-employment. Re-appraisal South Africa’s black box of precarious self-employment through the lens of Canadian dependent contractor jurisprudence points to key limitations that should be addressed for a more robust and effective vision of labour regulation. If the definition of “employee” in section 213 of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 is amended to redefine an “employee” to include a “dependent contractor”, this will represent a leap forward in tackling the interlinked problems of disguised employment and precarious self-employment. This statutory redefinition of the employee serves two purposes. First, the dependent contractor category solves the broader challenge for labour regulation of how to extend protection to persons who have some of the trappings of the independent contractor, but, in reality, are in a position of i ii economic dependence, resembling that of an employee. In essence, the intermediate category recognises that, as a matter of fairness persons in economic positions that are closely analogous should be given the same legislative treatment. The second purpose, and one no less important, is to fill in the missing piece of the puzzle in the judicially endorsed three-tiered SITA test for identifying employment relationship. If the dependent contractor category is adopted, the lacuna in the threefold SITA test that has so far escaped scholarly, judicial and legislative will be resolved. In this regard, the study contributes to a line of legal scholarship that has tracked the regulatory trajectory for reforming South Africa’s labour laws. It is hoped that this thesis will provoke a sustained, and more curious engagement with the complexities and capacities of labour regulation
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018
- Authors: Maloka, Tumo Charles
- Date: 2018
- Subjects: Labor laws and legislation
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Doctoral , LLD
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10353/16874 , vital:40781
- Description: The enormously intricate task of unmasking the true employee in contemporary work environment reveals the dilemmas and complexities embedded in the beguilingly simple but intractable question: who is an employee? The hallmarks of a true employee are shaded in modern work environment given that the actual differences between the categories of “employee” and “independent contractor” are diminishing. The conception of self-employment that links being self-employed inextricably with entrepreneurship, ownership, and autonomy has more to do with ideology than reality. In addressing the opacities of form engendered by “Work on demand via app” and the “Uberisation of work”, the study also attends to the significant and neglected component of labour law’s traditional dilemma. Put simply, how the law identifies an “employer” as a counterparty with an “employee”. Certain features of modern business organisation such as vertical disintegration of production, and their link to the rise of precarious employment underscore the extent to which the concept of employer plays a central role in defining the contours of labour protection. The problems of precarity are deep-seated, long-term and even escalating, especially in compelled and dependent self-employment. Re-appraisal South Africa’s black box of precarious self-employment through the lens of Canadian dependent contractor jurisprudence points to key limitations that should be addressed for a more robust and effective vision of labour regulation. If the definition of “employee” in section 213 of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 is amended to redefine an “employee” to include a “dependent contractor”, this will represent a leap forward in tackling the interlinked problems of disguised employment and precarious self-employment. This statutory redefinition of the employee serves two purposes. First, the dependent contractor category solves the broader challenge for labour regulation of how to extend protection to persons who have some of the trappings of the independent contractor, but, in reality, are in a position of i ii economic dependence, resembling that of an employee. In essence, the intermediate category recognises that, as a matter of fairness persons in economic positions that are closely analogous should be given the same legislative treatment. The second purpose, and one no less important, is to fill in the missing piece of the puzzle in the judicially endorsed three-tiered SITA test for identifying employment relationship. If the dependent contractor category is adopted, the lacuna in the threefold SITA test that has so far escaped scholarly, judicial and legislative will be resolved. In this regard, the study contributes to a line of legal scholarship that has tracked the regulatory trajectory for reforming South Africa’s labour laws. It is hoped that this thesis will provoke a sustained, and more curious engagement with the complexities and capacities of labour regulation
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2018