Observing and evaluating creative mathematical reasoning through selected VITALmaths video clips and collaborative argumentation
- Authors: Kellen, Matthew Earl
- Date: 2017
- Subjects: Mathematics Study and teaching (Secondary) South Africa Grahamstown , Mathematics Study and teaching (Secondary) Audio-visual aids , Reasoning , Mathematical ability
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , MEd
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/6107 , vital:21032
- Description: Creative mathematical reasoning is a definition that the NCS policies allude to when they indicate the necessity for students to, “identify and solve problems and make decisions using critical and creative thinking.”(NCS, 2011: 9). Silver (1997) and Lithner (2008) focus on creativity of reasoning in terms of the flexibility, fluency and novelty in which one approaches a mathematical problem. Learners who can creatively select appropriate strategies that are mathematically founded, and justify their answers use creative mathematical reasoning. This research uses Visual Technology for the Autonomous Learning of Mathematics (VITALmaths) video clips that pose mathematics problems to stimulate articulated reasoning among small multi-age, multi-ability Grade 9 peer groups. Using VITALmaths clips that pose visual and open-ended task, set the stage for collaborative argumentation between peers. This study observes creative mathematical reasoning in two ways: Firstly by observing the interaction between peers in the process of arriving at an answer, and secondly by examining the end product of the peer group’s justification of their solution. (Ball & Bass, 2003) Six grade 8 and 9 learners from no-fee public schools in the township of Grahamstown, South Africa were selected for this case study. Participants were a mixed ability, mixed gendered, sample group from an after-school programme which focused on creating a space for autonomous learning. The six participants were split into two groups and audio and video recorded as they solved selected VITALmaths tasks and presented their evidence and solutions to the tasks. Audio and video recordings and written work were used to translate, transcribe, and code participant interactions according to a framework adapted from Krummheuer (2007) and Lithner (2008) and Silver (1997) and Toulmin (1954). This constituted the analysis of the process of creative mathematical reasoning. Group presentations of evidence and solutions to the VITALmaths tasks, were used in conjunction with an evaluation framework adapted from Lithner (2008) and Campos (2010). This was the product analysis of creative mathematical reasoning. This research found that there was significant evidence of creative mathematical reasoning in the process and product evaluation of group interactions and solutions. Process analysis showed that participants were very active, engaged, and creative in their participation, but struggled to integrate and implement ideas cohesively. Product analysis similarly showed that depth and concentration of strategies implemented are key to correct and exhaustive mathematically grounded solutions.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2017
- Authors: Kellen, Matthew Earl
- Date: 2017
- Subjects: Mathematics Study and teaching (Secondary) South Africa Grahamstown , Mathematics Study and teaching (Secondary) Audio-visual aids , Reasoning , Mathematical ability
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , MEd
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/6107 , vital:21032
- Description: Creative mathematical reasoning is a definition that the NCS policies allude to when they indicate the necessity for students to, “identify and solve problems and make decisions using critical and creative thinking.”(NCS, 2011: 9). Silver (1997) and Lithner (2008) focus on creativity of reasoning in terms of the flexibility, fluency and novelty in which one approaches a mathematical problem. Learners who can creatively select appropriate strategies that are mathematically founded, and justify their answers use creative mathematical reasoning. This research uses Visual Technology for the Autonomous Learning of Mathematics (VITALmaths) video clips that pose mathematics problems to stimulate articulated reasoning among small multi-age, multi-ability Grade 9 peer groups. Using VITALmaths clips that pose visual and open-ended task, set the stage for collaborative argumentation between peers. This study observes creative mathematical reasoning in two ways: Firstly by observing the interaction between peers in the process of arriving at an answer, and secondly by examining the end product of the peer group’s justification of their solution. (Ball & Bass, 2003) Six grade 8 and 9 learners from no-fee public schools in the township of Grahamstown, South Africa were selected for this case study. Participants were a mixed ability, mixed gendered, sample group from an after-school programme which focused on creating a space for autonomous learning. The six participants were split into two groups and audio and video recorded as they solved selected VITALmaths tasks and presented their evidence and solutions to the tasks. Audio and video recordings and written work were used to translate, transcribe, and code participant interactions according to a framework adapted from Krummheuer (2007) and Lithner (2008) and Silver (1997) and Toulmin (1954). This constituted the analysis of the process of creative mathematical reasoning. Group presentations of evidence and solutions to the VITALmaths tasks, were used in conjunction with an evaluation framework adapted from Lithner (2008) and Campos (2010). This was the product analysis of creative mathematical reasoning. This research found that there was significant evidence of creative mathematical reasoning in the process and product evaluation of group interactions and solutions. Process analysis showed that participants were very active, engaged, and creative in their participation, but struggled to integrate and implement ideas cohesively. Product analysis similarly showed that depth and concentration of strategies implemented are key to correct and exhaustive mathematically grounded solutions.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2017
Investigating how the use of visual models can enhance the teaching of common fractions for conceptual understanding to Grade 8 learners
- Authors: Katenda, Aune Kashikuka
- Date: 2019
- Subjects: Fractions -- Study and teaching (Secondary)-- Namibia , Mathematics -- Study and teaching (Secondary)-- Namibia , Information visualization , Visual learning -- Case studies
- Language: English
- Type: text , Thesis , Masters , MEd
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/96746 , vital:31314
- Description: The intention of this study was to explore how selected mathematics teachers used visual models to improve the teaching of common fractions for conceptual understanding to Grade 8 learners as a result of an intervention programme. This research study is part of the VIPROmaths project which seeks to research the effective use of visualisation processes in the mathematics classroom in South Africa, Namibia, Zambia, Switzerland and Germany. This study which adopted a case study of teachers in Khomas Region, Namibia, is informed by constructivist learning theory. The study is situated within the interpretive paradigm and a multi-phase mixed method research approach was used. It focussed on analysing the use of visual models when teaching fractions namely: area model, number line model and a set model. The data were collected through survey questionnaires, observation and recall interview. The survey was conducted with the forty three mathematics teachers, from twenty secondary schools in Khomas region. The survey gave an overview of the nature and the use of visual models in schools. Three teachers purposively selected from the survey participated in the intervention program and were observed while teaching and interviewed after their teaching. Data were qualitatively and quantitatively analysed. The findings of this study reveal that visualising fractions is one of the methods that can improve both teaching and learning by providing concrete evidence of otherwise abstract ideas and concepts. The teachers highlighted that models themselves guide learners through to the answer, as compared to working out solutions using symbols only. They further indicated that visual models improve learners’ motivation, enhances understanding of fractions and encourages full participation of learners in the lesson. The study also found that use of visual models encouraged participation and it also boosted learners thinking capability. Teachers in this study preferred to use the area model as they found this model easier and more user-friendly in comparison with the number line and the set models. Teachers did not use the set model because of its complexity. This study concludes that the use of visual models can help enhance the conceptual teaching and understanding of common fractions. It is hoped that the study contributes towards improving the quality teaching and learning of fractions in Namibia. Furthermore, it informs the teacher-training institutions in Namibia to integrate the use of visualisation in their training programmes to promote conceptual understanding of mathematics.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2019
- Authors: Katenda, Aune Kashikuka
- Date: 2019
- Subjects: Fractions -- Study and teaching (Secondary)-- Namibia , Mathematics -- Study and teaching (Secondary)-- Namibia , Information visualization , Visual learning -- Case studies
- Language: English
- Type: text , Thesis , Masters , MEd
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/96746 , vital:31314
- Description: The intention of this study was to explore how selected mathematics teachers used visual models to improve the teaching of common fractions for conceptual understanding to Grade 8 learners as a result of an intervention programme. This research study is part of the VIPROmaths project which seeks to research the effective use of visualisation processes in the mathematics classroom in South Africa, Namibia, Zambia, Switzerland and Germany. This study which adopted a case study of teachers in Khomas Region, Namibia, is informed by constructivist learning theory. The study is situated within the interpretive paradigm and a multi-phase mixed method research approach was used. It focussed on analysing the use of visual models when teaching fractions namely: area model, number line model and a set model. The data were collected through survey questionnaires, observation and recall interview. The survey was conducted with the forty three mathematics teachers, from twenty secondary schools in Khomas region. The survey gave an overview of the nature and the use of visual models in schools. Three teachers purposively selected from the survey participated in the intervention program and were observed while teaching and interviewed after their teaching. Data were qualitatively and quantitatively analysed. The findings of this study reveal that visualising fractions is one of the methods that can improve both teaching and learning by providing concrete evidence of otherwise abstract ideas and concepts. The teachers highlighted that models themselves guide learners through to the answer, as compared to working out solutions using symbols only. They further indicated that visual models improve learners’ motivation, enhances understanding of fractions and encourages full participation of learners in the lesson. The study also found that use of visual models encouraged participation and it also boosted learners thinking capability. Teachers in this study preferred to use the area model as they found this model easier and more user-friendly in comparison with the number line and the set models. Teachers did not use the set model because of its complexity. This study concludes that the use of visual models can help enhance the conceptual teaching and understanding of common fractions. It is hoped that the study contributes towards improving the quality teaching and learning of fractions in Namibia. Furthermore, it informs the teacher-training institutions in Namibia to integrate the use of visualisation in their training programmes to promote conceptual understanding of mathematics.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2019
- «
- ‹
- 1
- ›
- »