The development and application of ecological risk assessment in South African water resource management
- Authors: Claassen, Marius
- Date: 2006
- Subjects: Ecological risk assessment -- South Africa Water resources development -- South Africa Water quality management -- South Africa Water-supply -- Management -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Doctoral , PhD
- Identifier: vital:6036 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1006177
- Description: The provision of goods and services by aquatic ecosystems plays an important role in socio-economic development and livelihoods in the southern African region. Water resource management in South Africa developed from an agrarian and pastoral focus up to 1956 to also supporting mining and industrial activities. This led to the introduction of the resource water quality objectives and pollution prevention approaches, which balanced the needs for development and protection. Prior to 1994, access to water resources was limited to riparian property owners and a minority of the population who controlled industrial and mining activities. The establishment of a democratic government amplified the need for accelerated socio-economic development, with equity, efficiency and sustainability being the principles of such development. New approaches were needed, which could achieve these development objectives and secure the resource base for future generations. An overview of the scientific process highlighted a risk based approach as potentially supporting the much needed balance between development and protection. The aims of this thesis is to develop a framework and process for the application of ecological risk assessment to water resource management in South Africa, to use case studies to draft guidelines for ecological risk assessment and to assess the degree to which ecological risk assessment can contribute to effective water resource management in South Africa. The United States Environmental Protection Agency’s guidelines for ecological risk assessment were identified amongst international best practice as meeting the requirements for local application. A framework was drafted for ecological risk assessment in South Africa, with the main phases being to agree on objectives, formulate the analysis plan, analyse information, characterise risk and manage risk. Modifications from the Environmental Protection Agency’s process include the order of activities in the first phase, the explicit testing of hypotheses and clarification of the evaluation of existing data or collection of new data. An industrial effluent case study was used to assess the applicability of the proposed framework. The case study dealt specifically with the assessment of risks posed by current conditions and long term licence conditions. The framework was found to be useful to identify weaknesses in the established monitoring programme and to evaluate lines of evidence to assess the degree to which the stated conditions would have unacceptable consequences. The study highlighted several weaknesses in the suggested framework, of which the most critical is the interpretation of the risk hypothesis as a testable null hypothesis. It became clear that cause-effect relationships should be stated as the risk hypothesis, whereas the assessment should evaluate expressed or expected conditions against a risk profile for a given stressor to benefit fully from the risk assessment approach. Changes to the framework terminology were suggested as well as nested feedback loops to allow for iterative processes where new information becomes available. The proposed guidelines incorporate the learning from the case study application as well as feedback from a peer review process. The guidelines incorporate the suggested actions under each phase as well as notes providing the rationale for each step. Three case study outlines were provided to assist users with the interpretation of the guidelines in different applications. The proposed guidelines are applied in an ecological Reserve determination case study, which specified the ecological water quality requirements. The study found that a risk-based approach was followed in the development of the water resource management policy, but the Reserve determination method is generally hazard based, with site specific modifications of the target values being allowed on a conservative basis. The case study highlighted a lack of readiness of water resource managers to accommodate scientific results expressed as probability distributions in support of management decisions. The thesis is concluded with a discussion of the key learning points of the ecological risk assessment development process. The evaluation highlights the move from stating and testing a null hypothesis to stating the risk hypothesis and evaluating the stated conditions against a risk profile. Several implementation challenges are highlighted, with specific recommendations made for adopting the proposed guidelines.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2006
- Authors: Claassen, Marius
- Date: 2006
- Subjects: Ecological risk assessment -- South Africa Water resources development -- South Africa Water quality management -- South Africa Water-supply -- Management -- South Africa
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Doctoral , PhD
- Identifier: vital:6036 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1006177
- Description: The provision of goods and services by aquatic ecosystems plays an important role in socio-economic development and livelihoods in the southern African region. Water resource management in South Africa developed from an agrarian and pastoral focus up to 1956 to also supporting mining and industrial activities. This led to the introduction of the resource water quality objectives and pollution prevention approaches, which balanced the needs for development and protection. Prior to 1994, access to water resources was limited to riparian property owners and a minority of the population who controlled industrial and mining activities. The establishment of a democratic government amplified the need for accelerated socio-economic development, with equity, efficiency and sustainability being the principles of such development. New approaches were needed, which could achieve these development objectives and secure the resource base for future generations. An overview of the scientific process highlighted a risk based approach as potentially supporting the much needed balance between development and protection. The aims of this thesis is to develop a framework and process for the application of ecological risk assessment to water resource management in South Africa, to use case studies to draft guidelines for ecological risk assessment and to assess the degree to which ecological risk assessment can contribute to effective water resource management in South Africa. The United States Environmental Protection Agency’s guidelines for ecological risk assessment were identified amongst international best practice as meeting the requirements for local application. A framework was drafted for ecological risk assessment in South Africa, with the main phases being to agree on objectives, formulate the analysis plan, analyse information, characterise risk and manage risk. Modifications from the Environmental Protection Agency’s process include the order of activities in the first phase, the explicit testing of hypotheses and clarification of the evaluation of existing data or collection of new data. An industrial effluent case study was used to assess the applicability of the proposed framework. The case study dealt specifically with the assessment of risks posed by current conditions and long term licence conditions. The framework was found to be useful to identify weaknesses in the established monitoring programme and to evaluate lines of evidence to assess the degree to which the stated conditions would have unacceptable consequences. The study highlighted several weaknesses in the suggested framework, of which the most critical is the interpretation of the risk hypothesis as a testable null hypothesis. It became clear that cause-effect relationships should be stated as the risk hypothesis, whereas the assessment should evaluate expressed or expected conditions against a risk profile for a given stressor to benefit fully from the risk assessment approach. Changes to the framework terminology were suggested as well as nested feedback loops to allow for iterative processes where new information becomes available. The proposed guidelines incorporate the learning from the case study application as well as feedback from a peer review process. The guidelines incorporate the suggested actions under each phase as well as notes providing the rationale for each step. Three case study outlines were provided to assist users with the interpretation of the guidelines in different applications. The proposed guidelines are applied in an ecological Reserve determination case study, which specified the ecological water quality requirements. The study found that a risk-based approach was followed in the development of the water resource management policy, but the Reserve determination method is generally hazard based, with site specific modifications of the target values being allowed on a conservative basis. The case study highlighted a lack of readiness of water resource managers to accommodate scientific results expressed as probability distributions in support of management decisions. The thesis is concluded with a discussion of the key learning points of the ecological risk assessment development process. The evaluation highlights the move from stating and testing a null hypothesis to stating the risk hypothesis and evaluating the stated conditions against a risk profile. Several implementation challenges are highlighted, with specific recommendations made for adopting the proposed guidelines.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2006
Structural studies on some enterobacterial capsular antigens
- Authors: Whittaker, Darryl Vanstone
- Date: 1994
- Subjects: Bacterial antigens -- Analysis Antigens Enterobacteriaceae Escherichia coli Klebsiella
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Doctoral , PhD
- Identifier: vital:3803 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1003281
- Description: The investigations presented in this thesis form part of a systematic international effort to establish the structures of the capsules produced by the bacterial genera, Escherichia coli and Klebsiella (family enterobacteriaceae). These bacteria are of medical interest as they are opportunistic pathogens and are frequently responsible for serious infections in animals and man. Invasive strains are invariably surrounded by a structurally complex polysaccharide capsule which contributes to the organism's ability to attenuate non-specific host defence mechanisms or, in some instances, to completely prevent an immune response. A knowledge of the chemical composition and structure of the capsule is, therefore, of great value as it provides insight into the mechanisms involved in this process. The E. coli, in particular, have generated considerable interest as their capsules are more structurally diverse and cross-reactivity with other, more pathogenic bacteria has also been demonstrated. Accordingly, the structures of three previously unstudied E. coli K-antigens viz. those produced by serotypes 020:K83:H26, 020:K84:H26, and 09:K48:H9 have been established by chemical and spectroscopic means and are presented in this thesis. In addition, a reinvestigation of the structure of the capsule produced by Klebsiella K15 using a novel enzymatic approach was also undertaken and a revised structure is proposed . The E. coli K48 polysaccharide is of special interest as it was found to contain a new diacetamido trideoxy hexose hitherto unrecorded. A synthesis for this saccharide is also presented. Finally, the application of lithium dissolved in ethylenediamine for the degradation of amino sugar-containing polysaccharides was also investigated using the capsular polysaccharides produced by E. coli serotypes K38 and K84 as model compounds.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 1994
- Authors: Whittaker, Darryl Vanstone
- Date: 1994
- Subjects: Bacterial antigens -- Analysis Antigens Enterobacteriaceae Escherichia coli Klebsiella
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Doctoral , PhD
- Identifier: vital:3803 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1003281
- Description: The investigations presented in this thesis form part of a systematic international effort to establish the structures of the capsules produced by the bacterial genera, Escherichia coli and Klebsiella (family enterobacteriaceae). These bacteria are of medical interest as they are opportunistic pathogens and are frequently responsible for serious infections in animals and man. Invasive strains are invariably surrounded by a structurally complex polysaccharide capsule which contributes to the organism's ability to attenuate non-specific host defence mechanisms or, in some instances, to completely prevent an immune response. A knowledge of the chemical composition and structure of the capsule is, therefore, of great value as it provides insight into the mechanisms involved in this process. The E. coli, in particular, have generated considerable interest as their capsules are more structurally diverse and cross-reactivity with other, more pathogenic bacteria has also been demonstrated. Accordingly, the structures of three previously unstudied E. coli K-antigens viz. those produced by serotypes 020:K83:H26, 020:K84:H26, and 09:K48:H9 have been established by chemical and spectroscopic means and are presented in this thesis. In addition, a reinvestigation of the structure of the capsule produced by Klebsiella K15 using a novel enzymatic approach was also undertaken and a revised structure is proposed . The E. coli K48 polysaccharide is of special interest as it was found to contain a new diacetamido trideoxy hexose hitherto unrecorded. A synthesis for this saccharide is also presented. Finally, the application of lithium dissolved in ethylenediamine for the degradation of amino sugar-containing polysaccharides was also investigated using the capsular polysaccharides produced by E. coli serotypes K38 and K84 as model compounds.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 1994
The influence of overwash and breaching events on the spatial and temporal patterns in ichthyofauna community composition in a temporarily open/closed southern African estuary
- Authors: Tweddle, Gavin Paul
- Date: 2013
- Subjects: Estuarine fishes -- Africa, Southern Marine fishes -- Africa, Southern Fishes -- Breeding -- Africa, Southern Fishes -- Effect of habitat modification on -- Africa, Southern Fishes -- Spawning -- Africa, Southern Gobiidae -- Africa, Southern Estuaries -- Africa, Southern Estuarine ecology -- Africa, Southern
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Doctoral , PhD
- Identifier: vital:5610 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1002957
- Description: This study assessed the importance of overwash and breaching events on the ichthyofaunal community structure in the medium-sized temporarily open/closed Mpekweni Estuary located on the southeast coastline of southern Africa. The fish in the littoral zone of the estuary were sampled using a 5m seine net while the channel region was sampled using two nets, a smaller meshed 30m seine net to target the estuarine spawning species and the juvenile estuarine-dependant marine spawners, and a larger meshed 50m seine net to target the larger marine and freshwater spawning species. Intensive monthly sampling over two years provided data on selected physico-chemical and biological parameters. During the two year sampling period from November 2005 to October 2007 the estuary breached in late July 2006 and remained open till the sandbar re-formed across the mouth in late December 2006. Thus, sampling encompassed three open/closed phases 1) initial closed period, 2) open period and 3) re-closed period after the berm was re-formed. The open period was divided into two phases 1) the out-flow phase and 2) the tidal phase. A total of 36 fish species representing 19 families were sampled using the various seine nets employed during the investigation. In the littoral zone, the estuarine spawners (Estuarine Utilisation Category, [EUC] I), mainly the Gobiidae, Glossogobius callidus, dominated the samples numerically and by biomass. The smaller estuarine spawning species sampled in the channel were numerically dominated by Gilchristella aestuaria in conjunction with two other EUC I species, Atherina breviceps and G. callidus. The estuarine-dependant marine spawners (EUC II), however, dominated the ichthyofaunal biomass of the channel. The abundance and biomass of the larger species targeted were dominated by estuarine-dependant marine spawning species (EUC II), principally Rhabdosargus holubi. During the closed periods of the estuary, total fish abundance and biomass displayed weak seasonal patterns. The breaching event and subsequent open period was associated with a decrease in the total abundances of fish in the littoral zone and channel of the estuary, reflecting the out-flow of estuarine biomass-rich water into the marine environment. The breaching event coincided with a shift in the community composition of the ichthyofauna, reflecting the recruitment of marine spawning species into the estuary. Numerical analysis identified two distinct spatial fish communities within the estuary, a community associated with the mouth region and one comprising the rest of the estuary. The absence of any further spatial patterns in the ichthyofaunal community structure within the Mpekweni Estuary appear to be ascribed to the virtual absence of horizontal patterns in physico-chemical and biological parameters recorded in the system. Cohort analyses were employed to determine possible recruitment events for selected estuarine and marine spawning species. The estuarine spawning species displayed continuous recruitment patterns throughout the study, which appeared to be unaffected by the breaching event. Conversely, the larger marine spawning species displayed multiple cohorts, indicating non-continuous recruitment. Subsequent retrospective analysis of cohorts for the different species identified summer recruitment peaks that coincided with the breaching event and open period. Minor recruitment of marine spawning species also occurred during overwash events. The recruitment of ichthyofauna into the estuary was quantified during three distinct hydrological events: overwash, out-flow phase immediately after breaching and tidal phase during the period when the mouth was open. Estimates of fish recruitment were highest during the outflow phase immediately after the estuary breached and declined as the estuary became tidally inundated with marine water. Although not as high as the outflow and tidal phases, recruitment was evident during overwash events. Results of the current study highlight the importance of both breaching and overwashing events in structuring the ichthyofaunal community composition in a medium-sized southern African temporarily open/closed estuary. These results are broadly in agreement with similar studies conducted both locally and in other regions of the world.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2013
- Authors: Tweddle, Gavin Paul
- Date: 2013
- Subjects: Estuarine fishes -- Africa, Southern Marine fishes -- Africa, Southern Fishes -- Breeding -- Africa, Southern Fishes -- Effect of habitat modification on -- Africa, Southern Fishes -- Spawning -- Africa, Southern Gobiidae -- Africa, Southern Estuaries -- Africa, Southern Estuarine ecology -- Africa, Southern
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Doctoral , PhD
- Identifier: vital:5610 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1002957
- Description: This study assessed the importance of overwash and breaching events on the ichthyofaunal community structure in the medium-sized temporarily open/closed Mpekweni Estuary located on the southeast coastline of southern Africa. The fish in the littoral zone of the estuary were sampled using a 5m seine net while the channel region was sampled using two nets, a smaller meshed 30m seine net to target the estuarine spawning species and the juvenile estuarine-dependant marine spawners, and a larger meshed 50m seine net to target the larger marine and freshwater spawning species. Intensive monthly sampling over two years provided data on selected physico-chemical and biological parameters. During the two year sampling period from November 2005 to October 2007 the estuary breached in late July 2006 and remained open till the sandbar re-formed across the mouth in late December 2006. Thus, sampling encompassed three open/closed phases 1) initial closed period, 2) open period and 3) re-closed period after the berm was re-formed. The open period was divided into two phases 1) the out-flow phase and 2) the tidal phase. A total of 36 fish species representing 19 families were sampled using the various seine nets employed during the investigation. In the littoral zone, the estuarine spawners (Estuarine Utilisation Category, [EUC] I), mainly the Gobiidae, Glossogobius callidus, dominated the samples numerically and by biomass. The smaller estuarine spawning species sampled in the channel were numerically dominated by Gilchristella aestuaria in conjunction with two other EUC I species, Atherina breviceps and G. callidus. The estuarine-dependant marine spawners (EUC II), however, dominated the ichthyofaunal biomass of the channel. The abundance and biomass of the larger species targeted were dominated by estuarine-dependant marine spawning species (EUC II), principally Rhabdosargus holubi. During the closed periods of the estuary, total fish abundance and biomass displayed weak seasonal patterns. The breaching event and subsequent open period was associated with a decrease in the total abundances of fish in the littoral zone and channel of the estuary, reflecting the out-flow of estuarine biomass-rich water into the marine environment. The breaching event coincided with a shift in the community composition of the ichthyofauna, reflecting the recruitment of marine spawning species into the estuary. Numerical analysis identified two distinct spatial fish communities within the estuary, a community associated with the mouth region and one comprising the rest of the estuary. The absence of any further spatial patterns in the ichthyofaunal community structure within the Mpekweni Estuary appear to be ascribed to the virtual absence of horizontal patterns in physico-chemical and biological parameters recorded in the system. Cohort analyses were employed to determine possible recruitment events for selected estuarine and marine spawning species. The estuarine spawning species displayed continuous recruitment patterns throughout the study, which appeared to be unaffected by the breaching event. Conversely, the larger marine spawning species displayed multiple cohorts, indicating non-continuous recruitment. Subsequent retrospective analysis of cohorts for the different species identified summer recruitment peaks that coincided with the breaching event and open period. Minor recruitment of marine spawning species also occurred during overwash events. The recruitment of ichthyofauna into the estuary was quantified during three distinct hydrological events: overwash, out-flow phase immediately after breaching and tidal phase during the period when the mouth was open. Estimates of fish recruitment were highest during the outflow phase immediately after the estuary breached and declined as the estuary became tidally inundated with marine water. Although not as high as the outflow and tidal phases, recruitment was evident during overwash events. Results of the current study highlight the importance of both breaching and overwashing events in structuring the ichthyofaunal community composition in a medium-sized southern African temporarily open/closed estuary. These results are broadly in agreement with similar studies conducted both locally and in other regions of the world.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2013
The dynamics of a subtropical lake fishery in central Mozambique
- Authors: Weyl, Olaf L F
- Date: 1999
- Subjects: Fisheries -- Chicamba, Lake Fisheries -- Mozambique
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Doctoral , PhD
- Identifier: vital:5212 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1004785
- Description: Fisheries in African reservoirs are typically multi -species and in most cases the fish resource is harvested with a number of gears. These characteristics complicate their management and the development of management procedures. Typically, long time series of data on catch and effort and length- or age-based catch are not available for these fisheries. This precludes the use of data intensive methods such as multi-species virtual population analysis. The principal aim of this thesis was to develop a management procedure for African reservoir fisheries that takes into account the pertinent biological characteristics of the target species and accounts for the multi-species and multi-gear irIteractions in such fisheries. An opportunity availed itself to undertake this work on Lake ChicaIllba (19°08'S 33°08'E) a man-made hydroelectric dam in subtropical Mozambique (Manica province). The specific objectives of this study were: to obtain locality specific biological parameters for the target species in Lake ChicaIllba; to assess gear utilisation trends in the fishery through the determination of gear-selectivity, catch rate and effort for each of the principal gears used in the fishery; to assess the fishery using traditional per-recruit models and to test existing and new per-recruit models that account for the multi-species and multi-gear nature of the fishery and to determine the adequacy of each of these approaches in the determination of suitable target reference point (TRP) exploitation rates. The three principal specIes in Lake Chicamba are the introduced largemouth bass, Micropterus salmoides, and two cichlids the Mozambique tilapia, Oreochromis mossambicus and the redbreast tilapia, Tilapia rendalli. Sectioned otoliths were used for age and growth determination. Marginal zone analysis showed that annulus formation in all three species occurred during winter. The maximum-recorded age was 5 years for M. salmoides, 16 years for T. rendalli and 10 years for O. mossambicus. Growth of the three species was best described by the 3 parameter von Bertalanffy growth model as ℓa = 465.51 (1 - e⁻ₑ·ₑ⁷⁵⁽a⁺⁰·⁰⁰⁹⁾ mm FL for M salmoides; ℓa = 238.74 (1 - e⁻⁰⁶³⁶⁽a⁺⁰·⁹⁰⁵⁾) mm TL for T. rendalli; and ℓa = 266.06 (1 - e⁻⁰⁷⁹⁰⁴⁽a⁺⁰·²⁶⁹⁾) mm TL for 0. mossambicus. Female T. rendalli attained 50%-maturity at 2.89 years, while O. mossambicus matured at 2.83 years and M. salmoides at 0.9 years. Both cichlid species spawned throughout summer while M. salmoides had a very short spawning season from August to September. The total annual mortality rate (Z) for M. salmoides in Lake Chicamba was 1.27 yr⁻¹, the mean empirical estimate of natural mortality (M) was 0.73 yr⁻¹, and fishing mortality (F) was calculated at 0.54 yr⁻¹. For T. rendalli Z = 0.31 yr⁻¹, M = 0.20 yr⁻¹, F = 0.11 yr⁻¹ and for 0. mossambicus Z= 0.62 yr⁻¹, M= 0.38 yr⁻¹, F= 0.24 yr⁻¹. The three species exhibited reproductive traits, which implied a high reliance of recruitment on spawner stock (nest guarding in T. rendalli and M. salmoides and mouthbrooding in O. mossambicus). For this reason it was decided that the cichlid fisheries should be managed using TRPs which maintained the spawner biomass-per-recruit at 50% (FSB50) of pristine levels. However, based on good evidence it was hypothesised that the high rate of fishing mortality helped to maintain the fast growth rate of M. salmoides. It was, therefore, decided to manage this species at a TRP of F SB40. The three most important fishing sectors were the gill-net, seine-net and hook-and-line fisheries. The total catch for 1996 was 223 t. The gill nets selected all three species at a size/age approximating 50%-maturity while the seine-net and hook-and-line fisheries selected mainly juvenile fishes. There was strong evidence to suggest that seine net fishing also disrupted spawning. It was shown that the 'traditional' single-species per-recruit models were unsuitable to assess multi-species and multi-gear reservoir fisheries. Since existing multi-species/multifishery yield-per-recruit models were not capable of defining FsB(x) TRPs, a new multispecies/ multi-fishery spawner-biomass-per-recruit approach was developed. This approach allowed for the simulation of the response of spawner biomass-per-recruit to changes in effort in the three fishery sectors, simultaneously. The models showed that the spawner biomass-per-recruit, at current effort levels, was higher than the suggested TRP for the three species. However, it was shown that an increase of 10% in current total effort would reduce spawner biomass-per-recruit to below the recommended TRP levels. With the closure of the seine-net fishery, gill-net effort could be increased to 338 fishers (340 for management purposes) and effort in the hook-and-line fishery could be increased by 30% before the TRP was reached. To maintain the fish stocks above TRP levels, effort control was considered to be the most effective management method. The main recommendations for Lake Chicamba were to close the seine-net fishery, to limit the gill-net fishery to 340 fishers (using 137-m long x 3-m deep gill nets) and to maintain the open access nature of the hook-and-line fishery. The multi-species/multi-fishery per-recruit approach allows for the meaningful simulation of various scenarios and provides relatively robust management options. In the absence of long time series of effort and age- or length-based catch data, this approach was considered as the most suitable assessment method for multi-species/multi-gear African reservoir fisheries.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 1999
- Authors: Weyl, Olaf L F
- Date: 1999
- Subjects: Fisheries -- Chicamba, Lake Fisheries -- Mozambique
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Doctoral , PhD
- Identifier: vital:5212 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1004785
- Description: Fisheries in African reservoirs are typically multi -species and in most cases the fish resource is harvested with a number of gears. These characteristics complicate their management and the development of management procedures. Typically, long time series of data on catch and effort and length- or age-based catch are not available for these fisheries. This precludes the use of data intensive methods such as multi-species virtual population analysis. The principal aim of this thesis was to develop a management procedure for African reservoir fisheries that takes into account the pertinent biological characteristics of the target species and accounts for the multi-species and multi-gear irIteractions in such fisheries. An opportunity availed itself to undertake this work on Lake ChicaIllba (19°08'S 33°08'E) a man-made hydroelectric dam in subtropical Mozambique (Manica province). The specific objectives of this study were: to obtain locality specific biological parameters for the target species in Lake ChicaIllba; to assess gear utilisation trends in the fishery through the determination of gear-selectivity, catch rate and effort for each of the principal gears used in the fishery; to assess the fishery using traditional per-recruit models and to test existing and new per-recruit models that account for the multi-species and multi-gear nature of the fishery and to determine the adequacy of each of these approaches in the determination of suitable target reference point (TRP) exploitation rates. The three principal specIes in Lake Chicamba are the introduced largemouth bass, Micropterus salmoides, and two cichlids the Mozambique tilapia, Oreochromis mossambicus and the redbreast tilapia, Tilapia rendalli. Sectioned otoliths were used for age and growth determination. Marginal zone analysis showed that annulus formation in all three species occurred during winter. The maximum-recorded age was 5 years for M. salmoides, 16 years for T. rendalli and 10 years for O. mossambicus. Growth of the three species was best described by the 3 parameter von Bertalanffy growth model as ℓa = 465.51 (1 - e⁻ₑ·ₑ⁷⁵⁽a⁺⁰·⁰⁰⁹⁾ mm FL for M salmoides; ℓa = 238.74 (1 - e⁻⁰⁶³⁶⁽a⁺⁰·⁹⁰⁵⁾) mm TL for T. rendalli; and ℓa = 266.06 (1 - e⁻⁰⁷⁹⁰⁴⁽a⁺⁰·²⁶⁹⁾) mm TL for 0. mossambicus. Female T. rendalli attained 50%-maturity at 2.89 years, while O. mossambicus matured at 2.83 years and M. salmoides at 0.9 years. Both cichlid species spawned throughout summer while M. salmoides had a very short spawning season from August to September. The total annual mortality rate (Z) for M. salmoides in Lake Chicamba was 1.27 yr⁻¹, the mean empirical estimate of natural mortality (M) was 0.73 yr⁻¹, and fishing mortality (F) was calculated at 0.54 yr⁻¹. For T. rendalli Z = 0.31 yr⁻¹, M = 0.20 yr⁻¹, F = 0.11 yr⁻¹ and for 0. mossambicus Z= 0.62 yr⁻¹, M= 0.38 yr⁻¹, F= 0.24 yr⁻¹. The three species exhibited reproductive traits, which implied a high reliance of recruitment on spawner stock (nest guarding in T. rendalli and M. salmoides and mouthbrooding in O. mossambicus). For this reason it was decided that the cichlid fisheries should be managed using TRPs which maintained the spawner biomass-per-recruit at 50% (FSB50) of pristine levels. However, based on good evidence it was hypothesised that the high rate of fishing mortality helped to maintain the fast growth rate of M. salmoides. It was, therefore, decided to manage this species at a TRP of F SB40. The three most important fishing sectors were the gill-net, seine-net and hook-and-line fisheries. The total catch for 1996 was 223 t. The gill nets selected all three species at a size/age approximating 50%-maturity while the seine-net and hook-and-line fisheries selected mainly juvenile fishes. There was strong evidence to suggest that seine net fishing also disrupted spawning. It was shown that the 'traditional' single-species per-recruit models were unsuitable to assess multi-species and multi-gear reservoir fisheries. Since existing multi-species/multifishery yield-per-recruit models were not capable of defining FsB(x) TRPs, a new multispecies/ multi-fishery spawner-biomass-per-recruit approach was developed. This approach allowed for the simulation of the response of spawner biomass-per-recruit to changes in effort in the three fishery sectors, simultaneously. The models showed that the spawner biomass-per-recruit, at current effort levels, was higher than the suggested TRP for the three species. However, it was shown that an increase of 10% in current total effort would reduce spawner biomass-per-recruit to below the recommended TRP levels. With the closure of the seine-net fishery, gill-net effort could be increased to 338 fishers (340 for management purposes) and effort in the hook-and-line fishery could be increased by 30% before the TRP was reached. To maintain the fish stocks above TRP levels, effort control was considered to be the most effective management method. The main recommendations for Lake Chicamba were to close the seine-net fishery, to limit the gill-net fishery to 340 fishers (using 137-m long x 3-m deep gill nets) and to maintain the open access nature of the hook-and-line fishery. The multi-species/multi-fishery per-recruit approach allows for the meaningful simulation of various scenarios and provides relatively robust management options. In the absence of long time series of effort and age- or length-based catch data, this approach was considered as the most suitable assessment method for multi-species/multi-gear African reservoir fisheries.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 1999
- «
- ‹
- 1
- ›
- »